Tongdong Bai: Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case

• Published in: Res Publica Vol. 27; no. 4; pp. 675 - 680
• Main Author: Jin Yutang
• Format: Book Review
• Language: English
• Published: Dordrecht Springer Nature B.V 01.11.2021
• Subjects: Compassion; Confucianism; Equality; Hierarchies; Political participation
• ISSN: 1356-4765; 1572-8692

Tongdong Bai’s ambitious book, Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case, aims to not only draw on classic Confucianism to shed light on contemporary issues but also make Confucianism universally applicable to the human conditions widely shared around the globe. Bai’s Confucian political theory carries distinctive merits in both its innovative approach and comprehensive scope, but there are still ambiguities of which he owes us more explanation. In this review article, I offer a brief summary of Bai’s book and critically engage with three aspects of his account: (1) the acceptability of the Confucian hybrid regime, (2) its relationship with Confucian compassion, and (3) hierarchical international order. First, Bai’s pursuit of service to the people as an end result makes it difficult to apply to societies that champion political equality and participation. Second, neither the supremacy of the Confucian value of compassion nor the hybrid regime’s ability to carry it through is self-evidently clear. Third, the Confucian idea of unity among all-under-heaven undermines Bai’s advocacy of patriotic allegiance to a particular state and hierarchical inter-state order where the multiplicity of states, albeit unequal, is preserved.