Antibiotic treatment of moderate-severe community-acquired pneumonia: design and rationale of a multicentre cluster-randomised cross-over trial

• Published in: Netherlands journal of medicine Vol. 72; no. 3; pp. 170 - 178
• Main Authors: van Werkhoven, C H, Postma, D F, Oosterheert, J J, Bonten, M J M
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands 01.04.2014
• Subjects: Anti-Bacterial Agents - therapeutic use; beta-Lactams - therapeutic use; Community-Acquired Infections - drug therapy; Cross-Over Studies; Drug Therapy, Combination; Fluoroquinolones - therapeutic use; Humans; Macrolides - therapeutic use; Observational Studies as Topic; Pneumonia, Bacterial - drug therapy; Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic; Research Design; Severity of Illness Index
• ISSN: 1872-9061

For the empirical treatment of community-acquired pneumonia requiring admission to a non-ICU ward, the Dutch guidelines recommend either beta-lactam monotherapy, beta-lactam and macrolide combination therapy, or fluoroquinolone monotherapy. The lack of convincing evidence to preferentially recommend any of the three empiric regimens results from intrinsic limitations of current studies, such as bias by indication and residual confounding in observational studies, and the unknown effects of pre-randomisation antibiotic use in randomised controlled trials. In this paper we discuss the methodological drawbacks of observational cohorts and randomised controlled trials in antibiotic therapy. Next, we explain why we designed a multicentre cluster-randomised cross-over study to evaluate the effectiveness of three antibiotic treatment strategies, consisting of a preferred treatment regimen of beta-lactam monotherapy, beta-lactam and macrolide combination therapy or fluoroquinolone monotherapy, in adult patients admitted to a non-ICU ward with a clinical diagnosis of community-acquired pneumonia. Furthermore we outline different aspects of this design that deserve thorough consideration. We discuss different aspects of a cluster-randomised cross-over trial that is designed to determine the effects of three recommended regimens of antibiotic treatment of CAP.