Benchmark CCSD(T) and DFT study of binding energies in Be7 - 12: in search of reliable DFT functional for beryllium clusters

• Published in: Molecular physics Vol. 116; no. 10; p. 1259
• Main Authors: Labanc, Daniel, S;ulka, Martin, Pitonák, Michal, Cernusák, Ivan, Urban, Miroslav, Neogrády, Pavel
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Abingdon Taylor & Francis Ltd 19.05.2018
• Subjects: Benchmarks; Beryllium; Binding energy; Clusters; Density functional theory; Electron states; Performance assessment; Variations
• ISSN: 0026-8976; 1362-3028
• DOI: 10.1080/00268976.2017.1420259

We present a computational study of the stability of small homonuclear beryllium clusters Be7 - 12 in singlet electronic states. Our predictions are based on highly correlated CCSD(T) coupled cluster calculations. Basis set convergence towards the complete basis set limit as well as the role of the 1s core electron correlation are carefully examined. Our CCSD(T) data for binding energies of Be7 - 12 clusters serve as a benchmark for performance assessment of several density functional theory (DFT) methods frequently used in beryllium cluster chemistry. We observe that, from Be10 clusters on, the deviation from CCSD(T) benchmarks is stable with respect to size, and fluctuating within 0.02 eV error bar for most examined functionals. This opens up the possibility of scaling the DFT binding energies for large Be clusters using CCSD(T) benchmark values for smaller clusters. We also tried to find analogies between the performance of DFT functionals for Be clusters and for the valence-isoelectronic Mg clusters investigated recently in Truhlar's group. We conclude that it is difficult to find DFT functionals that perform reasonably well for both beryllium and magnesium clusters. Out of 12 functionals examined, only the M06-2X functional gives reasonably accurate and balanced binding energies for both Be and Mg clusters.