해지드/보우타이 기법의 한계와 개선에 대하여

• Published in: 大韓造船學會 論文集 Vol. 59; no. 3; pp. 164 - 172
• Main Authors: 김성훈, Kim, Sung-Hoon
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English; Korean
• Published: 대한조선학회 01.06.2022
• Subjects: 조선공학
• ISSN: 1225-1143; 2287-7355
• DOI: 10.3744/SNAK.2022.59.3.164

A HAZID is a brainstorming workshop to identify hazards in an early phase of a project. It should be flexible to capture all probable accidents allowing experienced participants to exploit their expertise and experiences. A bowtie analysis is a graphical representation of major accident hazards elaborating safety measures i.e. barriers. The result of these workshops should be documented in an organized manner to share as good as possible details of the discussion through the lifetime of the project. Currently results are documented using a three-step representation of an accident; causes, top event and consequences, which cannot capture correctly sequence of events leading to various accidents and roles of barrier between two events. Another problem is that barriers would be shown repeatedly leading to a misunderstanding that there are an enough number of safety measures. A new bowtie analysis method is proposed to describe an accident in multiple steps showing relations among causes or consequences. With causes and consequences shown in a format of a tree, the frequencies of having the top event (Fault tree analysis) and various consequences (Event tree analysis) are evaluated automatically based on the frequency of initiating causes and the probabilities of failure of barriers. It will provide a good description of the accident scenario and help the risk to be assessed transparently.