Network localization of antisocial behavior in neurological patients: Evidence and implications

• Published in: Handbook of Clinical Neurology Vol. 197; pp. 45 - 54
• Main Author: Darby, R. Ryan
• Format: Book Chapter Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier Health Sciences 2023
• Subjects: Brain lesions; Brain networks; Criminal; Frontal lobe; Moral; Neurology; Value-based decision-making; Criminal; Neurology; Frontal lobe; Brain lesions; Brain networks; Value-based decision-making; Moral
• ISBN: 0128213752; 9780128213759
• ISSN: 0072-9752
• DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-821375-9.00009-8

Antisocial behavior may develop in otherwise normal persons as a result of neurological diseases, including patients with focal brain lesions, frontotemporal dementia, and Parkinson Disease patients taking dopamine agonist medications. Evidence from these neurological patients demonstrates that antisocial behaviors relate to dysfunction in several different brain regions that form a specific brain network, rather than any single location alone. This network associated with acquired antisocial behavior is involved in social decision-making (measured using moral decision-making tasks) and value-based decision-making (measured using neuroeconomic and reward-based tasks). Collectively, this work supports the hypothesis that antisocial behavior across different neurological diseases results from dysfunction within a common network of brain regions associated with social valuation and decision-making, providing insight into the neural mechanisms leading to acquired antisocial behavior. These findings have important implications, but also important limitations, for understanding criminal behavior in patients with psychopathy, for rehabilitation in criminals, for ethical discussions regarding moral and legal responsibility, and for forensic neurological evaluations in persons accused of crimes.