Racing toward Tragedy? China's Rise, Military Competition in the Asia Pacific, and the Security Dilemma

• Published in: International security Vol. 39; no. 2; pp. 52 - 91
• Main Authors: Liff, Adam P., Ikenberry, G. John
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: One Rogers Street, Cambridge, MA 02142-1209, USA The MIT Press 01.10.2014; MIT Press; MIT Press Journals, The
• Subjects: Armed conflict; ARMED FORCES; Arms Race; Arms races; Asia; Asia Pacific Region; China; China (People's Republic); Climate; Cold War (1945-1989); Competition; Competition (Psychology); Conflict; Defense policy; Defense spending; Dilemmas; Economic Development; ECONOMICS; Expenditures; Foreign policy; Foreign relations; International Relations; International security; Military defense; Military expenditure; Military policy; Military spending; Military strategy; National security; Peace; Peoples Republic of China; Political theory; RISK; Security dilemma; Territorial disputes; War; UNITED STATES; CHINA; Asia-Pacific region
• ISSN: 0162-2889; 1531-4804
• DOI: 10.1162/isec_a_00176

In the post–Cold War period, scholars have considered the Asia Pacific to be ripe for military competition and conflict. Developments over the past decade have deepened these expectations. Across the region, rising military spending and efforts of various states to bolster their military capabilities appear to have created an increasingly volatile climate, along with potentially vicious cycles of mutual arming and rearming. In this context, claims that China's rapid economic growth and surging military spending are fomenting destabilizing arms races and security dilemmas are widespread. Such claims make for catchy headlines, yet they are rarely subject to rigorous empirical tests. Whether patterns of military competition in the Asia Pacific are in fact attributable to a security dilemma–based logic has important implications for international relations theory and foreign policy. The answer has direct consequences for how leaders can maximize the likelihood that peace and stability will prevail in this economically and strategically vital region. A systematic empirical test derived from influential theoretical scholarship on the security dilemma concept assesses the drivers of bilateral and multilateral frictions and military competition under way in the Asia Pacific. Security dilemma–driven competition appears to be an important contributor, yet the outcome is not structurally determined. Although this military competition could grow significantly in the near future, there are a number of available measures that could help to ameliorate or manage some of its worst aspects.