Comparison and Relative Utility of Inequality Measurements: As Applied to Scotland’s Child Dental Health

• Published in: PloS one Vol. 8; no. 3; p. e58593
• Main Authors: Blair, Yvonne I., McMahon, Alex D., Macpherson, Lorna M. D.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Public Library of Science 08.03.2013; Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subjects: Child; Child health; Child, Preschool; Children & youth; Datasets; Dental caries; Dental Caries - epidemiology; Dental health; Deprivation; Epidemiological Monitoring; Epidemiology; Equality; Families & family life; Female; Health; Health disparities; Humans; Inequalities; Inequality; Libraries; Male; Mathematical analysis; Medicine; Methods; Models, Biological; Morbidity; Observer Variation; Oral hygiene; Population; Public health; Retrospective Studies; Scotland - epidemiology; Socio-economic aspects; Socioeconomic factors; Socioeconomics; Studies; Teeth; Trends; Scotland; Glasgow Scotland; United Kingdom > UK
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0058593

This study compared and assessed the utility of tests of inequality on a series of very large population caries datasets. National cross-sectional caries datasets for Scotland's 5-year-olds in 1993/94 (n = 5,078); 1995/96 (n = 6,240); 1997/98 (n = 6,584); 1999/00 (n = 6,781); 2002/03 (n = 9,747); 2003/04 (n = 10,956); 2005/06 (n = 10,945) and 2007/08 (n = 12,067) were obtained. Outcomes were based on the d3mft metric (i.e. the number of decayed, missing and filled teeth). An area-based deprivation category (DepCat) measured the subjects' socioeconomic status (SES). Simple absolute and relative inequality, Odds Ratios and the Significant Caries Index (SIC) as advocated by the World Health Organization were calculated. The measures of complex inequality applied to data were: the Slope Index of Inequality (absolute) and a variety of relative inequality tests i.e. Gini coefficient; Relative Index of Inequality; concentration curve; Koolman & Doorslaer's transformed Concentration Index; Receiver Operator Curve and Population Attributable Risk (PAR). Additional tests used were plots of SIC deciles (SIC(10)) and a Scottish Caries Inequality Metric (SCIM(10)). Over the period, mean d3mft improved from 3.1(95%CI 3.0-3.2) to 1.9(95%CI 1.8-1.9) and d3mft = 0% from 41.1(95%CI 39.8-42.3) to 58.3(95%CI 57.8-59.7). Absolute simple and complex inequality decreased. Relative simple and complex inequality remained comparatively stable. Our results support the use of the SII and RII to measure complex absolute and relative SES inequalities alongside additional tests of complex relative inequality such as PAR and Koolman and Doorslaer's transformed CI. The latter two have clear interpretations which may influence policy makers. Specialised dental metrics (i.e. SIC, SIC(10) and SCIM(10)) permit the exploration of other important inequalities not determined by SES, and could be applied to many other types of disease where ranking of morbidity is possible e.g. obesity. More generally, the approaches described may be applied to study patterns of health inequality affecting worldwide populations.