Roles for ordered and bulk solvent in ligand recognition and docking in two related cavities

• Published in: PloS one Vol. 8; no. 7; p. e69153
• Main Authors: Barelier, Sarah, Boyce, Sarah E, Fish, Inbar, Fischer, Marcus, Goodin, David B, Shoichet, Brian K
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Public Library of Science 18.07.2013; Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subjects: Affinity; Binding; Binding sites; Biochemistry; Biology; Chemical Sciences; Chemistry; Crystal structure; Crystallography; Cytochrome; Cytochrome c; Cytochrome-c Peroxidase - chemistry; Cytochrome-c Peroxidase - metabolism; Docking; Holes; Hydration; Kinases; Libraries; Ligands; Medical screening; Medicinal Chemistry; Models, Molecular; Molecular biology; Peroxidase; Pharmaceuticals; Pharmacy; Protein Binding - physiology; Protein Conformation; Proteins; Recognition; Solvation; Solvents; Solvents - chemistry; Water - chemistry; Water structure; United States > US; San Francisco California; California
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0069153

A key challenge in structure-based discovery is accounting for modulation of protein-ligand interactions by ordered and bulk solvent. To investigate this, we compared ligand binding to a buried cavity in Cytochrome c Peroxidase (CcP), where affinity is dominated by a single ionic interaction, versus a cavity variant partly opened to solvent by loop deletion. This opening had unexpected effects on ligand orientation, affinity, and ordered water structure. Some ligands lost over ten-fold in affinity and reoriented in the cavity, while others retained their geometries, formed new interactions with water networks, and improved affinity. To test our ability to discover new ligands against this opened site prospectively, a 534,000 fragment library was docked against the open cavity using two models of ligand solvation. Using an older solvation model that prioritized many neutral molecules, three such uncharged docking hits were tested, none of which was observed to bind; these molecules were not highly ranked by the new, context-dependent solvation score. Using this new method, another 15 highly-ranked molecules were tested for binding. In contrast to the previous result, 14 of these bound detectably, with affinities ranging from 8 µM to 2 mM. In crystal structures, four of these new ligands superposed well with the docking predictions but two did not, reflecting unanticipated interactions with newly ordered waters molecules. Comparing recognition between this open cavity and its buried analog begins to isolate the roles of ordered solvent in a system that lends itself readily to prospective testing and that may be broadly useful to the community.