Frail or hale: Skeletal frailty indices in Medieval London skeletons

• Published in: PloS one Vol. 12; no. 5; p. e0176025
• Main Authors: Marklein, Kathryn E, Crews, Douglas E
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Public Library of Science 03.05.2017; Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subjects: Anemia; Archaeology; Bioindicators; Biological markers; Biology; Biology and Life Sciences; Biomarkers; Biomarkers - metabolism; Cemeteries; Chronic illnesses; Correlation; Correlation coefficient; Correlation coefficients; Covariance; Disease; Epidemiology; Famine; Fossils; Frailty; Gender aspects; Genotype & phenotype; History, Medieval; Human remains; Humans; London; Medicine and Health Sciences; Mortality; People and Places; Physical anthropology; Physiology; Sample size; Samples; Sex; Sex differences; Skeleton; Social Sciences; Statistical analysis; Statistical methods; Statistics; Variance analysis; England; Ohio; United Kingdom > UK; United States > US
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0176025

To broaden bioarchaeological applicability of skeletal frailty indices (SFIs) and increase sample size, we propose indices with fewer biomarkers (2-11 non-metric biomarkers) and compare these reduced biomarker SFIs to the original metric/non-metric 13-biomarker SFI. From the 2-11-biomarker SFIs, we choose the index with the fewest biomarkers (6-biomarker SFI), which still maintains the statistical robusticity of a 13-biomarker SFI, and apply this index to the same Medieval monastic and nonmonastic populations, albeit with an increased sample size. For this increased monastic and nonmonastic sample, we also propose and implement a 4-biomarker SFI, comprised of biomarkers from each of four stressor categories, and compare these SFI distributions with those of the non-metric biomarker SFIs. From the Museum of London WORD database, we tabulate multiple SFIs (2- to 13-biomarkers) for Medieval monastic and nonmonastic samples (N = 134). We evaluate associations between these ten non-metric SFIs and the 13-biomarker SFI using Spearman's correlation coefficients. Subsequently, we test non-metric 6-biomarker and 4-biomarker SFI distributions for associations with cemetery, age, and sex using Analysis of Variance/Covariance (ANOVA/ANCOVA) on larger samples from the monastic and nonmonastic cemeteries (N = 517). For Medieval samples, Spearman's correlation coefficients show a significant association between the 13-biomarker SFI and all non-metric SFIs. Utilizing a 6-biomarker and parsimonious 4-biomarker SFI, we increase the nonmonastic and monastic samples and demonstrate significant lifestyle and sex differences in frailty that were not observed in the original, smaller sample. Results from the 6-biomarker and parsimonious 4-biomarker SFIs generally indicate similarities in means, explained variation (R2), and associated P-values (ANOVA/ANCOVA) within and between nonmonastic and monastic samples. We show that non-metric reduced biomarker SFIs provide alternative indices for application to other bioarchaeological collections. These findings suggest that a SFI, comprised of six or more non-metric biomarkers available for the specific sample, may have greater applicability than, but comparable statistical characteristics to, the originally proposed 13-biomarker SFI.