Evolution of female promiscuity in Passerides songbirds

• Published in: BMC ecology and evolution Vol. 19; no. 1; pp. 169 - 14
• Main Authors: Lifjeld, Jan T., Gohli, Jostein, Albrecht, Tomáš, Garcia-del-Rey, Eduardo, Johannessen, Lars Erik, Kleven, Oddmund, Marki, Petter Z., Omotoriogun, Taiwo C., Rowe, Melissah, Johnsen, Arild
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England BioMed Central Ltd 14.08.2019; BioMed Central; BMC
• Subjects: Analysis; Animal behavior; Animal reproduction; Animals; Behavior; Biological Evolution; Birds; Body Size; Bonds (Securities); Breeding; Coloration; Communal breeding; Ecology; Environmental aspects; Evolution; Evolutionary biology; Extrapair paternity; Female; Females; Hypotheses; Life history; Male; Males; Mating behavior; Mating system; Motor vehicle drivers; Natural history; Natural selection; Nest building; Nesting; Pair Bond; Parental care; Parenting; Passeri; Paternity; Phylogeny; Plumage; Population; Promiscuity; Sexual Behavior, Animal; Sexual selection; Songbirds; Songbirds - genetics; Songbirds - physiology; Species; Sperm; Taxonomy; Variation; Women's associations; Norway; Mating system; Parental care; Extrapair paternity; Life history; Sexual selection; Pair bond
• ISSN: 1471-2148; 1471-2148; 2730-7182
• DOI: 10.1186/s12862-019-1493-1

Female promiscuity is highly variable among birds, and particularly among songbirds. Comparative work has identified several patterns of covariation with social, sexual, ecological and life history traits. However, it is unclear whether these patterns reflect causes or consequences of female promiscuity, or if they are byproducts of some unknown evolutionary drivers. Moreover, factors that explain promiscuity at the deep nodes in the phylogenetic tree may be different from those important at the tips, i.e. among closely related species. Here we examine the relationships between female promiscuity and a broad set of predictor variables in a comprehensive data set (N = 202 species) of Passerides songbirds, which is a highly diversified infraorder of the Passeriformes exhibiting significant variation in female promiscuity. Female promiscuity was highly variable in all major clades of the Passerides phylogeny and also among closely related species. We found several significant associations with female promiscuity, albeit with fairly small effect sizes (all R  ≤ 0.08). More promiscuous species had: 1) less male parental care, particularly during the early stages of the nesting cycle (nest building and incubation), 2) more short-term pair bonds, 3) greater degree of sexual dichromatism, primarily because females were drabber, 4) more migratory behaviour, and 5) stronger pre-mating sexual selection. In a multivariate model, however, the effect of sexual selection disappeared, while the other four variables showed additive effects and together explained about 16% of the total variance in female promiscuity. Female promiscuity showed no relationship with body size, life history variation, latitude or cooperative breeding. We found that multiple traits were associated with female promiscuity, but these associations were generally weak. Some traits, such as reduced parental care in males and more cryptic plumage in females, might even be responses to, rather than causes of, variation in female promiscuity. Hence, the high variation in female promiscuity among Passerides species remains enigmatic. Female promiscuity seems to be a rapidly evolving trait that often diverges between species with similar ecologies and breeding systems. A future challenge is therefore to understand what drives within-lineage variation in female promiscuity over microevolutionary time scales.