Examining the implementation of a community paediatric clinic in a socially disadvantaged Irish community: A retrospective process evaluation

• Published in: PloS one Vol. 19; no. 2; p. e0295521
• Main Authors: Buckley, Lynn, Gibson, Louise, Harford, Katherine, Cornally, Nicola, Curtin, Margaret
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Public Library of Science 01.02.2024; Public Library of Science (PLoS)
• Subjects: Ambulatory Care Facilities; Analysis; Biology and Life Sciences; Child; Child development; Children; Community Health Services; Family; Focus Groups; Health aspects; Health Promotion; Humans; Medical research; Medicine and Health Sciences; Medicine, Experimental; Pediatric clinics; Pediatrics; People and Places; Practice; Psychological aspects; Retrospective Studies; Social aspects; Social Sciences; Ireland
• ISSN: 1932-6203; 1932-6203
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0295521

Understanding interventions and their implementation is essential for improving community initiatives. Kidscope is a community paediatric development clinic providing free health and developmental assessment and onward referral for children aged zero to six years in an urban area of southern Ireland where many children experience complex needs. Established in 2010, Kidscope developed an inter-disciplinary, multi-agency community team by drawing on the strengths of local services and practitioners to deliver holistic approaches to child health and development. Recent studies examining stakeholder engagement and Kidscope outcomes highlighted the need to examine implementation to better understand the processes and mechanisms of the clinic and how events have affected outcomes. Guided by the UK Medical Research Council Framework for Developing and Evaluating Complex Interventions, this study used a post-hoc qualitative process evaluation study design with multiple data sources; stakeholder perspectives (interviews, focus group, questionnaires) and document analysis (annual reports, meeting minutes, work plans). A diverse set of research questions were developed in conjunction with a Patient and Public Involvement Group. Guiding frameworks supported thematic analysis of primary data, document analysis of secondary data, and triangulation of findings across datasets. Data analysis yielded 17 themes and 18 sub-themes. Successful implementation hinged on developing a coalition of linked practitioners and services whose skills were utilised and enhanced within Kidscope to deliver a high-quality healthcare model to vulnerable children and families. Relational and multi-disciplinary working, innovative approaches to implementation and sustainability, training and education provision, and the accessible community location were among the mechanisms of change resulting in improved child, family, practitioner, and system-level outcomes. External factors such as COVID-19 and deficits in Ireland's disability services posed significant barriers to fidelity. This study provides evidence of the processes, mechanisms, and model of care employed by a community-based paediatric clinic to successfully engage society's most vulnerable families and promote health equity. This study makes an important contribution to the field of implementation research by offering an example of a robust approach to conceptualising and measuring implementation outcomes of community healthcare initiative in a changing, real-world context.