Harmonized-Multinational qEEG norms (HarMNqEEG)

• Published in: NeuroImage (Orlando, Fla.) Vol. 256; p. 119190
• Main Authors: Li, Min, Wang, Ying, Lopez-Naranjo, Carlos, Hu, Shiang, Reyes, Ronaldo César García, Paz-Linares, Deirel, Areces-Gonzalez, Ariosky, Hamid, Aini Ismafairus Abd, Evans, Alan C., Savostyanov, Alexander N., Calzada-Reyes, Ana, Villringer, Arno, Tobon-Quintero, Carlos A., Garcia-Agustin, Daysi, Yao, Dezhong, Dong, Li, Aubert-Vazquez, Eduardo, Reza, Faruque, Razzaq, Fuleah Abdul, Omar, Hazim, Abdullah, Jafri Malin, Galler, Janina R., Ochoa-Gomez, John F., Prichep, Leslie S., Galan-Garcia, Lidice, Morales-Chacon, Lilia, Valdes-Sosa, Mitchell J., Tröndle, Marius, Zulkifly, Mohd Faizal Mohd, Abdul Rahman, Muhammad Riddha Bin, Milakhina, Natalya S., Langer, Nicolas, Rudych, Pavel, Koenig, Thomas, Virues-Alba, Trinidad A., Lei, Xu, Bringas-Vega, Maria L., Bosch-Bayard, Jorge F., Valdes-Sosa, Pedro Antonio
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Elsevier Inc 01.08.2022; Elsevier Limited; Elsevier
• Subjects: Age; Batch effects; Brain; Collaboration; Covid induced brain dysfunction; Developmental Brain Chart; Developmental disabilities; EEG; EEG cross-spectrum; Electroencephalography; Harmonization; Life span; Malnutrition; Medical imaging; Neural networks; Neurodevelopmental disorders; Neuroimaging; Norms; Quality control; Quantitative EEG; Riemannian geometry; Statistical methods; Z-score; Riemannian geometry; EEG cross-spectrum; Z-score; Developmental Brain Chart; Covid induced brain dysfunction; Quantitative EEG; Malnutrition; Batch effects; Harmonization
• ISSN: 1053-8119; 1095-9572; 1095-9572
• DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2022.119190

•We create lifespan Riemannian qEEG norms for cross-spectral tensors.•EEG from 1564 subjects provided by 9 countries, 12 devices, and 14 studies were used.•We demonstrate qEEG “batch effects”, providing harmonization methods to remove them.•Multinational harmonized z-scores increase diagnostic accuracy of brain dysfunction.•Data and software are available for norm and individual z-scores calculation. This paper extends frequency domain quantitative electroencephalography (qEEG) methods pursuing higher sensitivity to detect Brain Developmental Disorders. Prior qEEG work lacked integration of cross-spectral information omitting important functional connectivity descriptors. Lack of geographical diversity precluded accounting for site-specific variance, increasing qEEG nuisance variance. We ameliorate these weaknesses. (i) Create lifespan Riemannian multinational qEEG norms for cross-spectral tensors. These norms result from the HarMNqEEG project fostered by the Global Brain Consortium. We calculate the norms with data from 9 countries, 12 devices, and 14 studies, including 1564 subjects. Instead of raw data, only anonymized metadata and EEG cross-spectral tensors were shared. After visual and automatic quality control, developmental equations for the mean and standard deviation of qEEG traditional and Riemannian DPs were calculated using additive mixed-effects models. We demonstrate qEEG “batch effects” and provide methods to calculate harmonized z-scores. (ii) We also show that harmonized Riemannian norms produce z-scores with increased diagnostic accuracy predicting brain dysfunction produced by malnutrition in the first year of life and detecting COVID induced brain dysfunction. (iii) We offer open code and data to calculate different individual z-scores from the HarMNqEEG dataset. These results contribute to developing bias-free, low-cost neuroimaging technologies applicable in various health settings.