Do carboximide-carboxylic acid combinations form co-crystals? The role of hydroxyl substitution on the formation of co-crystals and eutectics

• Published in: IUCrJ Vol. 2; no. Pt 3; pp. 341 - 351
• Main Authors: Kaur, Ramanpreet, Gautam, Raj, Cherukuvada, Suryanarayan, Guru Row, Tayur N
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England International Union of Crystallography 01.05.2015
• Subjects: Amides; Benzoic acid; Binding; carboximides; Carboxylic acids; Chemical properties; co-crystals; crystal structure; Eutectics; Formations; Hydroxyl groups; Identification and classification; Imides; Research Papers; Substitution reactions; crystal structure; eutectics; carboximides; co-crystals; carboxylic acids
• ISSN: 2052-2525; 2052-2525
• DOI: 10.1107/S2052252515002651

Carboxylic acids, amides and imides are key organic systems which provide understanding of molecular recognition and binding phenomena important in biological and pharmaceutical settings. In this context, studies of their mutual interactions and compatibility through co-crystallization may pave the way for greater understanding and new applications of their combinations. Extensive co-crystallization studies are available for carboxylic acid/amide combinations, but only a few examples of carboxylic acid/imide co-crystals are currently observed in the literature. The non-formation of co-crystals for carboxylic acid/imide combinations has previously been rationalized, based on steric and computed stability factors. In the light of the growing awareness of eutectic mixtures as an alternative outcome in co-crystallization experiments, the nature of various benzoic acid/cyclic imide combinations is established in this paper. Since an additional functional group can provide sites for new intermolecular inter-actions and, potentially, promote supramolecular growth into a co-crystal, benzoic acids decorated with one or more hydroxyl groups have been systematically screened for co-crystallization with one unsaturated and two saturated cyclic imides. The facile formation of an abundant number of hydroxybenzoic acid/cyclic carboximide co-crystals is reported, including polymorphic and variable stoichiometry co-crystals. In the cases where co-crystals did not form, the combinations are shown invariably to result in eutectics. The presence or absence and geometric disposition of hydroxyl functionality on benzoic acid is thus found to drive the formation of co-crystals or eutectics for the studied carboxylic acid/imide combinations.