Human Salmonellosis: Estimation of Dose-Illness from Outbreak Data

• Published in: Risk analysis Vol. 28; no. 2; pp. 427 - 440
• Main Authors: Bollaerts, Kaatje, Aerts, Marc, Faes, Christel, Grijspeerdt, Koen, Dewulf, Jeroen, Mintiens, Koen
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Malden, USA Blackwell Publishing Inc 01.04.2008; Blackwell Publishing Ltd
• Subjects: Accounts; Analysis; Availability; Data analysis; Data uncertainty; Disease Outbreaks; Diseases; Dosage; dose-illness; Epistemology; Estimation; Food; Food matrix; Food Microbiology; fractional polynomials; generalized linear mixed models; Generalized linear models; Healthy food; human Salmonellosis; Humans; Illnesses; Immunity; Immunity (Disease); Infections; Measurement; Medical research; Models, Biological; Models, Statistical; Mortality; outbreak studies; Outbreaks; Pathogens; Population; Probability; Public health; Random effects; Risk Assessment; Risk management; Salmonella; Salmonella - pathogenicity; Salmonella Food Poisoning - epidemiology; Salmonella Infections - microbiology; Studies; Susceptibility; Uncertainty; Variability; Virulence; Volunteers
• ISSN: 0272-4332; 1539-6924; 1539-6924
• DOI: 10.1111/j.1539-6924.2008.01038.x

The quantification of the relationship between the amount of microbial organisms ingested and a specific outcome such as infection, illness, or mortality is a key aspect of quantitative risk assessment. A main problem in determining such dose-response models is the availability of appropriate data. Human feeding trials have been criticized because only young healthy volunteers are selected to participate and low doses, as often occurring in real life, are typically not considered. Epidemiological outbreak data are considered to be more valuable, but are more subject to data uncertainty. In this article, we model the dose-illness relationship based on data of 20 Salmonella outbreaks, as discussed by the World Health Organization. In particular, we model the dose-illness relationship using generalized linear mixed models and fractional polynomials of dose. The fractional polynomial models are modified to satisfy the properties of different types of dose-illness models as proposed by Teunis et al. Within these models, differences in host susceptibility (susceptible versus normal population) are modeled as fixed effects whereas differences in serovar type and food matrix are modeled as random effects. In addition, two bootstrap procedures are presented. A first procedure accounts for stochastic variability whereas a second procedure accounts for both stochastic variability and data uncertainty. The analyses indicate that the susceptible population has a higher probability of illness at low dose levels when the combination pathogen-food matrix is extremely virulent and at high dose levels when the combination is less virulent. Furthermore, the analyses suggest that immunity exists in the normal population but not in the susceptible population.