Comparing Dynamic User Equilibrium and Noniterative Stochastic Route Choice in a Simulation-Based Dynamic Traffic Assignment Model: Practical Considerations for Large-Scale Networks

• Published in: Journal of advanced transportation Vol. 2021; pp. 1 - 16
• Main Authors: Ashfaq, Mudabber, Gu, Ziyuan, Waller, S. Travis, Saberi, Meead
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Hindawi 05.05.2021; John Wiley & Sons, Inc; Wiley
• Subjects: Analysis; Assignment problem; Behavior; Computer applications; Equilibrium; Methods; Optimization; Route choice; Route selection; Simulation; Strategic planning (Business); Technology application; Traffic assignment; Traffic congestion; Traffic models; Traffic planning; Transportation; Transportation models; Transportation networks; Transportation planning; Vehicles; Australia
• ISSN: 0197-6729; 2042-3195
• DOI: 10.1155/2021/6667335

Simulation-based dynamic traffic assignment (DTA) models play a vital role in transportation planning and operations. While the widely studied equilibrium-seeking DTA including dynamic user equilibrium (DUE) often provides robust and consistent outcomes, their expensive computational cost for large-scale network applications has been a burden in practice. The noniterative stochastic route choice (SRC) model, as a nonequilibrium seeking DTA model, provides an alternative for specific transportation operations applications that may not require equilibrium results after all (e.g., evacuation and major network disruptions) and thus tend to be computationally less expensive, yet may suffer from inconsistent outcomes. While DUE is a widely accepted approach for many strategic planning applications, SRC has been increasingly used in practice for traffic operations purposes. This paper aims to provide a comparative and quantitative analysis of the two modeling approaches. Specifically, a comparison has been made at two levels: link-level flows and network-level congestion patterns. Results suggest that adaptive driving improves the quality of the SRC solution, but its difference from DUE still remains significant at the link level. Results have practical implications for the application of large-scale simulation-based DTA models for planning and operations purposes.