Consumers' and providers' perspectives about consumer participation in drug treatment services: is there support to do more? What are the obstacles?

• Published in: Drug and alcohol review Vol. 27; no. 2; pp. 138 - 144
• Main Authors: Bryant, Joanne, Saxton, Melissa, Madden, Annie, Bath, Nicky, Robinson, Suzanne
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford, UK Informa UK Ltd 01.03.2008; Blackwell Publishing Ltd
• Subjects: Attitude of Health Personnel; Attitude to Health; Attitudes; Australia; barriers; Community Participation - trends; Consumer participation; Consumers; Decision making; Drug abuse; drug treatment services; Health services; Humans; Mental Health Services - manpower; Mental Health Services - organization & administration; New South Wales; opinions; Patients; Performance appraisal; Social Support; Statistics; Substance-Related Disorders - rehabilitation; Surveys; user involvement; Victoria; Western Australia
• ISSN: 0959-5236; 1465-3362
• DOI: 10.1080/09595230701829405

Introduction and Aims. Implementing consumer participation initiatives in Australian drug treatment services successfully is predicated on the support of those most centrally involved. This paper describes service providers' and consumers' (1) beliefs about and commitment to consumer participation; and (2) perceived barriers to conducting or participating in consumer participation. Design and Methods. Data were collected from 64 providers and 179 consumers of drug treatment services. Results. The data showed that almost all consumers (89.9%, n = 161) and providers (84.4%, n = 54) believed in the principle of consumer participation (that consumers' views should be included in service planning and delivery) and a large proportion would be willing to conduct or participate in consumer participation activities in future. Providers were less supportive of activities in which consumers would be involved in decision-making that relates directly to staff (such as staff training, recruitment and performance appraisal), and expressed concerns about the practicality of operationalising such activities, the inadequacy of consumers' skills, consumers' lack of interest and the appropriateness of having consumers involved in such decision-making. A small proportion of consumers also indicated that they did not want to participate, expressing beliefs that it was not their place to be involved and that they lacked the required skills. Conclusions. Overall, these findings revealed that there was considerable support for the further development of consumer participation in drug treatment services, but the predominant obstacle was the view that it is not consumers' place to take part, and that they lack the interest and skills to do so. [Bryant J, Saxton M, Madden A, Bath N, Robinson S. Consumers' and providers' perspectives about consumer participation in drug treatment services: is there support to do more? What are the obstacles? Drug Alcohol Rev 2008;27:138-144]