Gorillas with white sclera: A naturally occurring variation in a morphological trait linked to social cognitive functions

• Published in: American journal of primatology Vol. 77; no. 8; pp. 869 - 877
• Main Authors: Mayhew, Jessica A., Gómez, Juan-Carlos
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Blackwell Publishing Ltd 01.08.2015; Wiley Subscription Services, Inc
• Subjects: Animals; Color; Communication; Eye - anatomy & histology; eye morphology; Eye Movements; gaze camouflaging; gaze following; Gorilla gorilla - anatomy & histology; Gorillas; Human biology; Humans; Morphology; Pigmentation; Primates; Primatology; Sclera - anatomy & histology; Social Behavior; white sclera; white sclera; eye morphology; gaze following; gorillas; gaze camouflaging
• ISSN: 0275-2565; 1098-2345
• DOI: 10.1002/ajp.22411

Human eye morphology is considered unique among the primates in that humans possess larger width/height ratios (WHR), expose a greater amount of visible sclera (SSI; width of exposed eyeball/width of visible iris), and critically, have a white sclera due to a lack of pigmentation. White sclera in humans amplifies gaze direction, whereas the all‐dark eyes of apes are hypothesized to conceal gaze from others. This study examines WHR and SSI in humans (N = 13) and gorillas (N = 85) engaged in direct and averted gazes and introduces a qualitative assessment of sclera color to evaluate variations in sclera pigmentation. The results confirm previous findings that humans possess a larger WHR than gorillas but indicate that humans and gorillas display similar amounts of visible sclera. Additionally, 72% (N = 124) of gorilla eyes in this sample deviated from the assumed all‐dark eye condition. This questions whether gaze camouflage is the primary function of darkened sclera in non‐human primates or whether other functional roles can be ascribed to the sclera, light or dark. We argue that white sclera evolved to amplify direct gazes in humans, which would have played a significant role in the development of ostensive communication, which is communication that both shows something and shows the intention to show something. We conclude that the horizontal elongation of the human eye, rather than sclera color, more reliably distinguishes human from great ape eyes, represented here by gorillas. Am. J. Primatol. 77:869–877, 2015. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.