The choice of sequence homologs included in multiple sequence alignments has a dramatic impact on evolutionary conservation analysis

• Published in: Bioinformatics Vol. 35; no. 1; pp. 12 - 19
• Main Authors: Gil, Nelson, Fiser, Andras
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Oxford University Press 01.01.2019
• Subjects: Algorithms; Binding Sites; Computational Biology; Conserved Sequence; Original Papers; Proteins - chemistry; Sequence Alignment; Sequence Analysis, Protein; Sequence Homology, Amino Acid
• ISSN: 1367-4803; 1460-2059; 1367-4811
• DOI: 10.1093/bioinformatics/bty523

Abstract Motivation The analysis of sequence conservation patterns has been widely utilized to identify functionally important (catalytic and ligand-binding) protein residues for over a half-century. Despite decades of development, on average state-of-the-art non-template-based functional residue prediction methods must predict ∼25% of a protein’s total residues to correctly identify half of the protein’s functional site residues. The overwhelming proportion of false positives results in reported ‘F-Scores’ of ∼0.3. We investigated the limits of current approaches, focusing on the so-far neglected impact of the specific choice of homologs included in multiple sequence alignments (MSAs). Results The limits of conservation-based functional residue prediction were explored by surveying the binding sites of 1023 proteins. A straightforward conservation analysis of MSAs composed of randomly selected homologs sampled from a PSI-BLAST search achieves average F-Scores of ∼0.3, a performance matching that reported by state-of-the-art methods, which often consider additional features for the prediction in a machine learning setting. Interestingly, we found that a simple combinatorial MSA sampling algorithm will in almost every case produce an MSA with an optimal set of homologs whose conservation analysis reaches average F-Scores of ∼0.6, doubling state-of-the-art performance. We also show that this is nearly at the theoretical limit of possible performance given the agreement between different binding site definitions. Additionally, we showcase the progress in this direction made by Selection of Alignment by Maximal Mutual Information (SAMMI), an information-theory-based approach to identifying biologically informative MSAs. This work highlights the importance and the unused potential of optimally composed MSAs for conservation analysis. Supplementary information Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.