Estimating the heritability of cognitive traits across dog breeds reveals highly heritable inhibitory control and communication factors

• Published in: Animal cognition Vol. 23; no. 5; pp. 953 - 964
• Main Authors: Gnanadesikan, Gitanjali E., Hare, Brian, Snyder-Mackler, Noah, MacLean, Evan L.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Berlin/Heidelberg Springer Berlin Heidelberg 01.09.2020; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Animal behavior; Behavioral Sciences; Biomedical and Life Sciences; Body weight; Cognition; Cognition & reasoning; Cognitive ability; Communication; Dogs; Domestic animals; Domestication; Evolution; Factor analysis; Genetic diversity; Heritability; Life Sciences; Memory; Original Paper; Phenotypes; Psychology Research; Reasoning; Zoology; Cognitive evolution; Domestication; Test battery; Citizen science; Breed differences; Canine cognition
• ISSN: 1435-9448; 1435-9456
• DOI: 10.1007/s10071-020-01400-4

Trait heritability is necessary for evolution by both natural and artificial selection, yet we know little about the heritability of cognitive traits. Domestic dogs are a valuable study system for questions regarding the evolution of phenotypic diversity due to their extraordinary intraspecific variation. While previous studies have investigated morphological and behavioral variation across dog breeds, few studies have systematically assessed breed differences in cognition. We integrated data from Dognition.com—a citizen science project on dog cognition—with breed-averaged genetic data from published sources to estimate the among-breed heritability of cognitive traits using mixed models. The resulting dataset included 11 cognitive measures for 1508 adult dogs across 36 breeds. A factor analysis yielded four factors interpreted as reflecting inhibitory control, communication, memory, and physical reasoning. Narrow-sense among-breed heritability estimates—reflecting the proportion of cognitive variance attributable to additive genetic variation—revealed that scores on the inhibitory control and communication factors were highly heritable (inhibitory control: h 2  = 0.70; communication: h 2  = 0.39), while memory and physical reasoning were less heritable (memory: h 2  = 0.17; physical reasoning: h 2  = 0.21). Although the heritability of inhibitory control is partially explained by body weight, controlling for breed-average weight still yields a high heritability estimate ( h 2  = 0.50), while other factors are minimally affected. Our results indicate that cognitive phenotypes in dogs covary with breed relatedness and suggest that cognitive traits have strong potential to undergo selection. The highest heritabilities were observed for inhibitory control and communication, both of which are hypothesized to have been altered by domestication.