The evolution of parasitic and mutualistic plant–virus symbioses through transmission-virulence trade-offs

• Published in: Virus research Vol. 241; pp. 77 - 87
• Main Authors: Hamelin, Frédéric M., Hilker, Frank M., Sun, T. Anthony, Jeger, Michael J., Hajimorad, M. Reza, Allen, Linda J.S., Prendeville, Holly R.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands Elsevier B.V 15.09.2017; Elsevier
• Subjects: Adaptive dynamics; Bi-stability; Horizontal; Life Sciences; Seed; Vector; Vegetal Biology; Vertical; Vertical; Bi-stability; Horizontal; Adaptive dynamics; Vector; Seed
• ISSN: 0168-1702; 1872-7492
• DOI: 10.1016/j.virusres.2017.04.011

•We use adaptive dynamics theory to study the evolution of plant–virus symbioses.•Ecological bistability in a discrete-time model with frequency-dependent transmission.•Darwinian extinction can occur under optimizing selection.•Evolutionary branching of parasitic and mutualistic viral symbioses.•Mutualism can outcompete parasitism in the long-run. Virus–plant interactions range from parasitism to mutualism. Viruses have been shown to increase fecundity of infected plants in comparison with uninfected plants under certain environmental conditions. Increased fecundity of infected plants may benefit both the plant and the virus as seed transmission is one of the main virus transmission pathways, in addition to vector transmission. Trade-offs between vertical (seed) and horizontal (vector) transmission pathways may involve virulence, defined here as decreased fecundity in infected plants. To better understand plant–virus symbiosis evolution, we explore the ecological and evolutionary interplay of virus transmission modes when infection can lead to an increase in plant fecundity. We consider two possible trade-offs: vertical seed transmission vs infected plant fecundity, and horizontal vector transmission vs infected plant fecundity (virulence). Through mathematical models and numerical simulations, we show (1) that a trade-off between virulence and vertical transmission can lead to virus extinction during the course of evolution, (2) that evolutionary branching can occur with subsequent coexistence of mutualistic and parasitic virus strains, and (3) that mutualism can out-compete parasitism in the long-run. In passing, we show that ecological bi-stability is possible in a very simple discrete-time epidemic model. Possible extensions of this study include the evolution of conditional (environment-dependent) mutualism in plant viruses.