Rational Choice and Progress in the Study of Ethnic Conflict: A Review Essay

• Published in: Security studies Vol. 14; no. 1; pp. 178 - 207
• Main Author: Kaufmann, Chaim
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Taylor & Francis Group 01.01.2005; Taylor & Francis Ltd
• Subjects: Comparative analysis; Conflict; Conflicts; Cultural Conflict; Essentialism; Ethnic Relations; Interethnic conflict; International relations; Literature; Methods; Minority & ethnic groups; Nationalism; Political Violence; Rational Choice; Rationality; Review articles; Social Conflict; Structuralism; Theory
• ISSN: 0963-6412; 1556-1852
• DOI: 10.1080/09636410591002554

Through an analysis of eight recent books and a number of articles and papers, this article evaluates recent progress in the study of ethnic conflict, including large scale conflicts and episodic riots. Four main approaches have been applied to the study of ethnic conflict: rational choice, constructivism, essentialism, and structuralism (or realism). This evaluation of recent work includes that rational choice has been the least successful of the approaches; its focus on individuals' pursuit of (mainly) material benefits makes it difficult to recognize or to admit the explanatory power of nationalist feelings that do not depend on the prospect of material benefits. Constructivism has been the most influential approach over the past few decades but until recently has suffered from methodological weaknesses that have hindered testing. Essentialism has been out favor for as long as constructivism has been in, but recent methodological improvements have produced strong work that has resurrected this approach. Structuralism is the youngest approach; it is still immature but has already yielded important new insights. Some eclectic approaches are emerging that combine strengths of the latter three approaches; it remains to be seen whether comparable eclecticism will combine rational choice with one or more of the others. Chaim Kaufmann is associate professor of international relations at Lehigh University.