Variation in Antibiotic Treatment Failure Outcome Definitions in Randomised Trials and Observational Studies of Antibiotic Prescribing Strategies: A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis

• Published in: Antibiotics (Basel) Vol. 11; no. 5; p. 627
• Main Authors: Neill, Rebecca, Gillespie, David, Ahmed, Haroon
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Switzerland MDPI AG 06.05.2022; MDPI
• Subjects: Antibiotics; Clinical trials; Failure; Health care; Hospitalization; Infections; Observational studies; observational study; Patients; Pneumonia; Primary care; randomised trial; Respiratory tract; Review; Soft tissues; Terminology; treatment failure; Urinary tract; Urinary tract diseases; Urinary tract infections; Urogenital system; Variation; United States > US; Pakistan; treatment failure; randomised trial; observational study
• ISSN: 2079-6382; 2079-6382
• DOI: 10.3390/antibiotics11050627

Antibiotic treatment failure is used as an outcome in randomised trials and observational studies of antibiotic treatment strategies and may comprise different events that indicate failure to achieve a desired clinical response. However, the lack of a universally recognised definition has led to considerable variation in the types of events included. We undertook a systematic review of published studies investigating antibiotic treatment strategies for common uncomplicated infections, aiming to describe variation in terminology and components of the antibiotic treatment failure outcomes. We searched Medline, Embase, and the Cochrane Central Register of Clinical trials for English language studies published between January 2010 and January 2021. The population of interest was ambulatory patients seen in primary care or outpatient settings with respiratory tract (RTI), urinary tract (UTI), or skin and soft tissue infection (SSTI), where different antibiotic prescribing strategies were compared, and the outcome was antibiotic treatment failure. We narratively summarised key features from eligible studies and used frequencies and proportions to describe terminology, components, and time periods used to ascertain antibiotic treatment failure outcomes. Database searches identified 2967 unique records, from which 36 studies met our inclusion criteria. This included 10 randomised controlled trials and 26 observational studies, with 20 studies of RTI, 12 of UTI, 4 of SSTI, and 2 of both RTI and SSTI. We identified three key components of treatment failure definitions: prescription changes, escalation of care, and change in clinical condition. Prescription changes were most popular in studies of UTI, while changes in clinical condition were most common in RTI and SSTI studies. We found substantial variation in the definition of antibiotic treatment failure in included studies, even amongst studies of the same infection subtype and study design. Considerable further work is needed to develop a standardised definition of antibiotic treatment failure in partnership with patients, clinicians, and relevant stakeholders.