Epistemologies of evidence-based medicine: a plea for corpus-based conceptual research in the medical humanities

• Published in: Medicine, health care, and philosophy Vol. 24; no. 4; pp. 621 - 632
• Main Authors: Buts, Jan, Baker, Mona, Luz, Saturnino, Engebretsen, Eivind
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Dordrecht Springer Netherlands 01.12.2021; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Education; Ethics; Evidence-Based Medicine; Humanities; Humans; Knowledge; Medical Law; Medicine; Philosophy; Philosophy of Biology; Philosophy of Medicine; Scientific Contribution; Theory of Medicine/Bioethics; Basic concept; Evidence; Corpora; Evidence-based medicine; Social epistemology
• ISSN: 1386-7423; 1572-8633; 1572-8633
• DOI: 10.1007/s11019-021-10027-2

Evidence-based medicine has been the subject of much controversy within and outside the field of medicine, with its detractors characterizing it as reductionist and authoritarian, and its proponents rejecting such characterization as a caricature of the actual practice. At the heart of this controversy is a complex linguistic and social process that cannot be illuminated by appealing to the semantics of the modifier evidence-based . The complexity lies in the nature of evidence as a basic concept that circulates in both expert and non-expert spheres of communication, supports different interpretations in different contexts, and is inherently open to contestation. We outline a new methodology that combines a social epistemological perspective with advanced methods of corpus linguistics and elements of conceptual history to investigate this and other basic concepts that underpin the practice and ethos of modern medicine. The potential of this methodology to offer new insights into controversies such as those surrounding EBM is demonstrated through a case study of the various meanings supported by evidence and based , as attested in a large electronic corpus of online material written by non-experts as well as a variety of experts in different fields, including medicine.