Midtarsal break variation in modern humans: Functional causes, skeletal correlates, and paleontological implications

• Published in: American journal of physical anthropology Vol. 156; no. 4; pp. 543 - 552
• Main Authors: DeSilva, J.M., Bonne-Annee, R., Swanson, Z., Gill, C.M., Sobel, M., Uy, J., Gill, S.V.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Blackwell Publishing Ltd 01.04.2015; Wiley Subscription Services, Inc
• Subjects: Animals; arch; Australopithecus; Foot - anatomy & histology; Foot - physiology; Fossils; fourth metatarsal; Hominidae - anatomy & histology; Hominidae - physiology; Hominids; Human remains; Humans; Linear Models; Metatarsal Bones - anatomy & histology; Metatarsal Bones - physiology; midfoot; Paleontology; Primate biology; Primates; pronation; Walking - physiology; pronation; Australopithecus; midfoot; arch; fourth metatarsal
• ISSN: 0002-9483; 1096-8644; 2692-7691
• DOI: 10.1002/ajpa.22699

ABSTRACT The midtarsal break was once treated as a dichotomous, non‐overlapping trait present in the foot of non‐human primates and absent in humans. Recent work indicates that there is considerable variation in human midfoot dorsiflexion, with some overlap with the ape foot. These findings have called into question the uniqueness of the human lateral midfoot, and the use of osteological features in fossil hominins to characterize the midfoot of our extinct ancestors. Here, we present data on plantar pressure and pedal mechanics in a large sample of adults and children (n = 671) to test functional hypotheses concerning variation in midfoot flexibility. Lateral midfoot peak plantar pressure correlates with both sagittal plane flexion at the lateral tarsometatarsal joint, and dorsiflexion at the hallucal metatarsophalangeal joint. The latter finding suggests that midfoot laxity may compromise hallucal propulsion. Multiple regression statistics indicate that a low arch and pronation of the foot explain 40% of variation in midfoot peak plantar pressure, independent of age and BMI. MRI scans on a small subset of study participants (n = 19) reveals that curvature of the base of the 4th metatarsal correlates with lateral midfoot plantar pressure and that specific anatomies of foot bones do indeed reflect relative midfoot flexibility. However, while the shape of the base of the 4th metatarsal may reliably reflect midfoot mobility in individual hominins, given the wide range of overlapping variation in midfoot flexibility in both apes and humans, we caution against generalizing foot function in extinct hominin species until larger fossils samples are available. Am J Phys Anthropol 156:543–552, 2015. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.