Endless Forms: Within-Host Variation in the Structure of the West Nile Virus RNA Genome during Serial Passage in Bird Hosts

• Published in: mSphere Vol. 4; no. 3
• Main Authors: Scroggs, Stacey L P, Grubaugh, Nathan D, Sena, Johnny A, Sundararajan, Anitha, Schilkey, Faye D, Smith, Darci R, Ebel, Gregory D, Hanley, Kathryn A
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States American Society for Microbiology 26.06.2019
• Subjects: 5' Untranslated Regions; Animals; Antiviral agents; Binding sites; Birds; Birds - virology; Complementarity; Crows - microbiology; Culicidae - virology; Ecological and Evolutionary Science; evolution; Genetic analysis; Genetic diversity; Genetic Variation; Genome, Viral; Genomes; High-Throughput Nucleotide Sequencing; Hypotheses; Mutation; natural selection; Next-generation sequencing; Nucleotide sequence; Phenotypes; Phenotypic variations; Proofreading; Protein structure; quasispecies; Replication; RNA virus; RNA viruses; RNA, Viral - genetics; Secondary structure; Serial Passage; Swarms; Translation; Virus Replication; Viruses; West Nile virus; West Nile virus - genetics; West Nile virus - physiology; New Mexico; United States > US; Colorado; secondary structure; genetic diversity; natural selection; RNA virus; West Nile virus; untranslated region; evolution; quasispecies
• ISSN: 2379-5042; 2379-5042
• DOI: 10.1128/mSphere.00291-19

RNA viruses are infamous for their high rates of mutation, which produce swarms of genetic variants within individual hosts. To date, analyses of intrahost genetic diversity have focused on the primary genome sequence. However, virus phenotypes are shaped not only by primary sequence but also by the secondary structures into which this sequence folds. Such structures enable viral replication, translation, and binding of small RNAs, yet within-host variation at the structural level has not been adequately explored. We characterized the structural diversity of the 5' untranslated region (UTR) of populations of West Nile virus (WNV) that had been subject to five serial passages in triplicate in each of three bird species. Viral genomes were sampled from host serum samples at each passage (  = 45 populations) and subjected to next-generation sequencing. For populations derived from passages 1, 3, and 5 (  = 9 populations), we predicted the impact of each mutation occurring at a frequency of ≥1% on the secondary structure of the 5' UTR. As expected, mutations in double-stranded (DS) regions of the 5' UTR stem structures caused structural changes of significantly greater magnitude than did mutations in single-stranded (SS) regions. Despite the greater impact of mutations in DS regions, mutations in DS and SS regions occurred at similar frequencies, with no evidence of enhanced selection against mutation in DS regions. In contrast, mutations in two regions that mediate genome cyclization and thereby regulate replication and translation, the 5' cyclization sequence and the UAR flanking stem (UFS), were suppressed in all three hosts. The enzymes that copy RNA genomes lack proofreading, and viruses that possess RNA genomes, such as West Nile virus, rapidly diversify into swarms of mutant lineages within a host. Intrahost variation of the primary genomic sequence of RNA viruses has been studied extensively because the extent of this variation shapes key virus phenotypes. However, RNA genomes also form complex secondary structures based on within-genome nucleotide complementarity, which are critical regulators of the cyclization of the virus genome that is necessary for efficient replication and translation. We sought to characterize variation in these secondary structures within populations of West Nile virus during serial passage in three bird species. Our study indicates that the intrahost population of West Nile virus is a diverse assortment of RNA secondary structures that should be considered in future analyses of intrahost viral diversity, but some regions that are critical for genome cyclization are conserved within hosts. Besides potential impacts on viral replication, structural diversity can influence the efficacy of small RNA antiviral therapies.