Invited review: Use of meta-analysis in animal health and reproduction: Methods and applications

• Published in: Journal of dairy science Vol. 92; no. 8; pp. 3545 - 3565
• Main Authors: Lean, I.J., Rabiee, A.R., Duffield, T.F., Dohoo, I.R.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: New York, NY Elsevier Inc 01.08.2009; American Dairy Science Association; Am Dairy Sci Assoc; Elsevier
• Subjects: animal health; Animal productions; animal reproduction; animal well-being; Animals; Bayesian theory; Biological and medical sciences; case definition; dairy cow; data analysis; epidemiology; estimation; Food industries; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; literature reviews; livestock; meta-analysis; Meta-Analysis as Topic; methodology; Milk and cheese industries. Ice creams; Publication Bias; quantitative analysis; Reproduction - physiology; Review Literature as Topic; risk factors; sample size; statistical analysis; Statistics as Topic; Terrestrial animal productions; Vertebrates; Veterinary Medicine - methods; meta-analysis; dairy cow; sample size; case definition; Farming animal; Sample; Size; Dairy cattle; Review; Vertebrata; Reproduction; Mammalia; Animal health; Dairy industry; Application method; Artiodactyla; Ungulata
• ISSN: 0022-0302; 1525-3198
• DOI: 10.3168/jds.2009-2140

The objectives of this paper are to provide an introduction to meta-analysis and systematic review and to discuss the rationale for this type of research and other general considerations. We highlight methods used to produce a rigorous meta-analysis and discuss some aspects of interpretation of meta-analysis drawing on examples from the animal and veterinary science literature. Meta-analysis is a rapidly expanding area of research that has been relatively underutilized in animal and veterinary science. It is a quantitative, formal, epidemiological study design used to systematically assess previous research studies to derive conclusions about that body of research. Outcomes from a meta-analysis may include a more precise estimate of the effect of treatment or risk factor for disease, or other outcomes, than any individual study contributing to the pooled analysis. The examination of variability or heterogeneity in study results is also a critical outcome. The benefits of meta-analysis include a consolidated and quantitative review of a large, and often complex, sometimes apparently conflicting, body of literature. Meta-analytic methods place less emphasis on dichotomous outcomes from null hypothesis significance testing and greater emphasis on determining the magnitude and the precision of an effect of interest. A substantial benefit of meta-analysis is the potential to investigate new hypotheses using existing data, both through the development of a priori hypotheses and by examination of the heterogeneity in study responses. The specification of the outcome and hypotheses that are tested is critical to the conduct of meta-analyses, as is a sensitive literature search. A failure to identify the majority of existing studies can lead to erroneous conclusions; however, there are methods of examining data to identify the potential for studies to be missing; for example, by the use of funnel plots. Many of the statistical methods to conduct meta-analysis are widely used. Bayesian methods are well suited to meta-analysis. The post-hoc methods used to evaluate heterogeneity and publication bias, which include the I2 statistic, L’Abbé plots, Galbraith plots, Rosenthal's N, and influential study analysis are exclusively used in meta-analysis. Examples where meta-analyses have been repeated in animal science or veterinary medicine show good consistency in estimates of effect. Findings of studies to date have provided new understandings of rumen modifiers, milk fever, parasite control, mastitis, somatotropin, and reproductive manipulations. Rigorously conducted meta-analyses are useful tools to improve animal well-being and productivity. The need to integrate findings from many studies ensures that meta-analytic research is desirable and the large body of research now generated makes the conduct of this research feasible.