The price of freedom: Open access, editorial labour, and prestige in academic publishing

• Published in: Island studies journal Vol. 18; no. 1; pp. 285 - 295
• Main Authors: Grydehøj, Adam, Su, Ping
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Charlottetown Institute of Island Studies 01.05.2023; Institute of Island Studies, University of Prince Edward Island; Island Studies Journal
• Subjects: Access; Bibliometrics; Costs; Diamonds; Editorials; Labour costs; Open access journals; Open access publishing; Production management; Professionals; Profitability; Profits; Publishing industry; Scholarly publishing; Subscriptions
• ISSN: 1715-2593; 1715-2593
• DOI: 10.24043/isj.422

This paper discusses tensions in journal editing and management, particularly for non-fee charging open access (diamond open access) journals. Even diamond open access journals and other journals published on a non-commercial basis are subject to financial and labour costs. Because diamond open access journals do not gain income from subscriptions or article processing charges (APCs), every published paper presents additional costs. Whereas commercially published journals depend upon substantial free academic labour, unfunded or underfunded diamond open access journals depend upon both substantial free academic labour and free non-academic labour. This encourages editors to be selective about the kinds of submissions on which they spend their time. The importance of maintaining a journal’s prestige, as measured through inclusion in bibliometric indices, incentivises further selectivity. Different kinds of papers are suitable for different kinds of journals. Even publications like Island Studies Journal that are radically accessible to authors and readers in diverse financial circumstances must make difficult choices when deciding what material to publish.