Does organic grassland farming benefit plant and arthropod diversity at the expense of yield and soil fertility?

• Published in: Agriculture, ecosystems & environment Vol. 177; pp. 1 - 9
• Main Authors: Klaus, Valentin H., Kleinebecker, Till, Prati, Daniel, Gossner, Martin M., Alt, Fabian, Boch, Steffen, Gockel, Sonja, Hemp, Andreas, Lange, Markus, Müller, Jörg, Oelmann, Yvonne, Pašalić, Esther, Renner, Swen C., Socher, Stephanie A., Türke, Manfred, Weisser, Wolfgang W., Fischer, Markus, Hölzel, Norbert
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford Elsevier B.V 01.09.2013; Elsevier
• Subjects: Agri-environmental schemes; Agricultural and farming systems; Agriculture; Agronomy. Soil science and plant productions; Animal, plant and microbial ecology; Applied ecology; Araneae; Arthropoda; Arthropods; Auchenorrhyncha; biodiversity; Biological and medical sciences; Biomass nutrient concentrations; Coleoptera; environmental impact; farming systems; Fertilization; Fodder quality; forage quality; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; General agroecology; General agroecology. Agricultural and farming systems. Agricultural development. Rural area planning. Landscaping; General agronomy. Plant production; Generalities. Agricultural and farming systems. Agricultural development; Grasslands; Hemiptera; Heteroptera; Land use; Land-use intensity; Management; meadows; Nitrogen; Nutrient availability; Organic farming; pastures; permanent grasslands; Phosphorus; Plants (organisms); range management; seed dispersal; seeds; Soil (material); soil fertility; Soil-plant relationships. Soil fertility; Soil-plant relationships. Soil fertility. Fertilization. Amendments; Species richness; vascular plants; Germany; Fertilization; Agri-environmental schemes; Biomass nutrient concentrations; Phosphorus; Nutrient availability; Organic farming; Nitrogen; Fodder quality; Land-use intensity; Species richness; Soil fertility; Fodder; Biomass; Land use; Grassland management; Organic agriculture; Arthropoda; Nutrient; Profit; Chemical concentration; Yield; Invertebrata; Agri-environmental measure
• ISSN: 0167-8809; 1873-2305
• DOI: 10.1016/j.agee.2013.05.019

•Organic management is able to promote arthropod biodiversity in grasslands.•No trend towards higher plant diversity was found in organic grasslands.•Organic farming does not bring severe economical losses in yield or soil fertility.•No differences in the effect of organic farming among grassland types were found. Organic management is one of the most popular strategies to reduce negative environmental impacts of intensive agriculture. However, little is known about benefits for biodiversity and potential worsening of yield under organic grasslands management across different grassland types, i.e. meadow, pasture and mown pasture. Therefore, we studied the diversity of vascular plants and foliage-living arthropods (Coleoptera, Araneae, Heteroptera, Auchenorrhyncha), yield, fodder quality, soil phosphorus concentrations and land-use intensity of organic and conventional grasslands across three study regions in Germany. Furthermore, all variables were related to the time since conversion to organic management in order to assess temporal developments reaching up to 18 years. Arthropod diversity was significantly higher under organic than conventional management, although this was not the case for Araneae, Heteroptera and Auchenorrhyncha when analyzed separately. On the contrary, arthropod abundance, vascular plant diversity and also yield and fodder quality did not considerably differ between organic and conventional grasslands. Analyses did not reveal differences in the effect of organic management among grassland types. None of the recorded abiotic and biotic parameters showed a significant trend with time since transition to organic management, except soil organic phosphorus concentrations which decreased with time. This implies that permanent grasslands respond slower and probably weaker to organic management than crop fields do. However, as land-use intensity and inorganic soil phosphorus concentrations were significantly lower in organic grasslands, overcoming seed and dispersal limitation by re-introducing plant species might be needed to exploit the full ecological potential of organic grassland management. We conclude that although organic management did not automatically increase the diversity of all studied taxa, it is a reasonable and useful way to support agro-biodiversity.