Large wood as a confounding factor in interpreting the width of spring-fed streams

• Published in: Earth surface dynamics Vol. 8; no. 1; pp. 195 - 210
• Main Authors: Lapides, Dana Ariel, Manga, Michael
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Gottingen Copernicus GmbH 19.03.2020; Copernicus Publications
• Subjects: Channel morphology; Climate; Climatic data; Comparative analysis; Confounding (Statistics); Creeks & streams; Daylighting; Digital media; Discharge; Glacial streams; Histograms; Hydrographs; Hydrologic data; Image resolution; Imagery; Length; Log jams; Morphology; Orientation; Remote sensing; Residence time; River channels; Rivers; Runoff; Satellite imagery; Satellites; Snow; Spaceborne remote sensing; Spring; Streams; Time; Width; Wood; Oregon; Montana; United States > US; Deschutes River; Idaho; Arizona
• ISSN: 2196-632X; 2196-6311; 2196-632X
• DOI: 10.5194/esurf-8-195-2020

Spring-fed streams throughout volcanic regions of the western United States exhibit larger widths than runoff-fed streams with similar discharge. Due to the distinctive damped hydrograph of spring-fed streams (as compared to large peaks visible in the hydrographs of runoff-fed streams), large wood is less mobile in spring-fed than runoff-fed stream channels, so wood is more likely to remain in place than form logjams as in runoff-fed streams. The consequent long residence time of wood in spring-fed streams allows wood to potentially have long-term impacts on channel morphology. We used high-resolution satellite imagery in combination with discharge and climate data from published reports and publicly available databases to investigate the relationship between discharge, wood length, and channel width in 38 spring-fed and 20 runoff-fed streams, additionally responding to a call for increased use of remote sensing to study wood dynamics and daylighting previously unpublished data. We identified an order of magnitude more logjams than single logs per unit length present in runoff-fed streams as compared to spring-fed streams. Histograms of log orientation in spring-fed streams additionally confirmed that single logs are immobile in the channel so that the impact of single logs on channel morphology could be pronounced in spring-fed streams. Based on these observed differences, we hypothesized that there should be a difference in channel morphology. A model for stream width in spring-fed streams based solely on length of wood is a better model than one derived from discharge or including both discharge and wood length. This study provides insights into controls on stream width in spring-fed streams.