Bistability and Nonmonotonic Induction of the lac Operon in the Natural Lactose Uptake System

• Published in: Biophysical journal Vol. 112; no. 9; pp. 1984 - 1996
• Main Authors: Zander, Dominique, Samaga, Daniel, Straube, Ronny, Bettenbrock, Katja
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Elsevier Inc 09.05.2017; Biophysical Society; The Biophysical Society
• Subjects: beta-Galactosidase - biosynthesis; beta-Galactosidase - genetics; Bistability; Cells; Computer applications; Culture Media; Data processing; Dilution; E coli; Enzyme Induction; Enzymes; Escherichia coli - genetics; Escherichia coli - metabolism; Escherichia coli Proteins - genetics; Escherichia coli Proteins - metabolism; Feedback; Feedback loops; Galactose - metabolism; Gene expression; Gene Expression Regulation, Bacterial; Glucose - metabolism; Growth rate; Lac Operon; Lactose; Lactose - metabolism; Lactose operon; Mathematical models; Microscopy, Fluorescence; Models, Biological; Positive feedback; Saturation; Succinic Acid - metabolism; Systems Biophysics
• ISSN: 0006-3495; 1542-0086
• DOI: 10.1016/j.bpj.2017.03.038

The Escherichia coli lac operon is regulated by a positive feedback loop whose potential to generate an all-or-none response in single cells has been a paradigm for bistable gene expression. However, so far bistable lac induction has only been observed using gratuitous inducers, raising the question about the biological relevance of bistable lac induction in the natural setting with lactose as the inducer. In fact, the existing experimental evidence points to a graded rather than an all-or-none response in the natural lactose uptake system. In contrast, predictions based on computational models of the lactose uptake pathway remain controversial. Although some argue in favor of bistability, others argue against it. Here, we reinvestigate lac operon expression in single cells using a combined experimental/modeling approach. To this end, we parameterize a well-supported mathematical model using transient measurements of LacZ activity upon induction with different amounts of lactose. The resulting model predicts a monostable induction curve for the wild-type system, but indicates that overexpression of the LacI repressor would drive the system into the bistable regime. Both predictions were confirmed experimentally supporting the view that the wild-type lac induction circuit generates a graded response rather than bistability. More interestingly, we find that the lac induction curve exhibits a pronounced maximum at intermediate lactose concentrations. Supported by our data, a model-based analysis suggests that the nonmonotonic response results from saturation of the LacI repressor at low inducer concentrations and dilution of Lac enzymes due to an increased growth rate beyond the saturation point. We speculate that the observed maximum in the lac expression level helps to save cellular resources by limiting Lac enzyme expression at high inducer concentrations.