Questioning the legitimacy of bariatric surgery: a qualitative analysis of individuals from the community who qualify for bariatric surgery

• Published in: Surgical endoscopy Vol. 36; no. 9; pp. 6733 - 6741
• Main Authors: Chao, Grace F., Diaz, Adrian, Ghaferi, Amir A., Dimick, Justin B., Byrnes, Mary E.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: New York Springer US 01.09.2022; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: 2021 SAGES Oral; Abdominal Surgery; Bariatric Surgery; Comorbidity; Data analysis; Endoscopy; Female; Gastroenterology; Gastrointestinal surgery; Gynecology; Health care policy; Hepatology; Hispanic or Latino; Humans; Iterative methods; Legitimacy; Male; Medical referrals; Medicine; Medicine & Public Health; Obesity; Obesity - surgery; Obesity, Morbid - surgery; Pacific Islander people; Proctology; Qualitative Research; Surgery; Weight control; Weight Loss; Patient perspectives; Bariatric surgery utilization
• ISSN: 0930-2794; 1432-2218
• DOI: 10.1007/s00464-021-08949-2

Background Little is known about how individuals in the community who qualify for bariatric surgery perceive it and how this affects their likelihood to consider it for themselves. This study is the first qualitative study of a racially and ethnically diverse cohort to understand perceptions of bariatric surgery. Methods We designed a descriptive study to understand attitudes about bariatric surgery. We interviewed 32 individuals who met NIH criteria for bariatric surgery but have never considered bariatric surgery. We purposively sampled to ensure the majority of participants were non-white. Using an Interpretive Description framework, an exploratory, iterative method was used to code interviews and arrive at final themes. Results Participants self-identified as 88% female, 75% Black, 3% Hispanic, 3% Pacific Islander, and 19% white. Three major themes emerged from our data regarding legitimacy of bariatric surgery. First, participants perceived bariatric surgery to be something commercialized rather than needed treatment. They equated bariatric surgery with “botulism of the lips” or “cool sculpting.” Second, an important contributor to the lack of legitimacy as a medical treatment was that many had not heard about bariatric surgery before from their doctors. Doctors were trusted sources for legitimate information about health. Lastly, conflicting information over bariatric surgery-related diet and weight loss further diminished the legitimacy of bariatric surgery. As one participant reflected about pre-operative weight loss requirements, “[If] I'm going to do that, I might as well just keep losing the weight. Why even go do the surgery?”. Conclusion Though bariatric surgery is a safe, effective, and durable therapy for patients with obesity, the majority of individuals we interviewed had concerns over the legitimacy of bariatric surgery as a medical treatment. Moving forward in reaching out to communities about bariatric surgery, healthcare providers and systems should consider the presentation of information to attenuate these concerns.