Experimental validation of a multinomial processing tree model for analyzing eyewitness identification decisions

• Published in: Scientific reports Vol. 12; no. 1; pp. 15571 - 18
• Main Authors: Winter, Kristina, Menne, Nicola M., Bell, Raoul, Buchner, Axel
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Nature Publishing Group UK 16.09.2022; Nature Publishing Group; Nature Portfolio
• Subjects: 631/477; 631/477/2811; Cognitive ability; Crime; Excipients; Experiments; Humanities and Social Sciences; Humans; Mental Recall; multidisciplinary; Police; Recognition, Psychology; Science; Science (multidisciplinary)
• ISSN: 2045-2322; 2045-2322
• DOI: 10.1038/s41598-022-19513-w

To improve police protocols for lineup procedures, it is helpful to understand the processes underlying eyewitness identification performance. The two-high threshold (2-HT) eyewitness identification model is a multinomial processing tree model that measures four latent cognitive processes on which eyewitness identification decisions are based: two detection-based processes (the detection of culprit presence and absence) and two non-detection-based processes (biased and guessing-based selection). The model takes into account the full 2 × 3 data structure of lineup procedures, that is, suspect identifications, filler identifications and rejections in both culprit-present and culprit-absent lineups. Here the model is introduced and the results of four large validation experiments are reported, one for each of the processes specified by the model. The validation experiments served to test whether the model’s parameters sensitively reflect manipulations of the processes they were designed to measure. The results show that manipulations of exposure duration of the culprit’s face at encoding, lineup fairness, pre-lineup instructions and ease of rejection of culprit-absent lineups were sensitively reflected in the parameters representing culprit-presence detection, biased suspect selection, guessing-based selection and culprit-absence detection, respectively. The results of the experiments thus validate the interpretations of the parameters of the 2-HT eyewitness identification model.