Investigating students' meaning-making of multiple visual representations of epigenetics at different levels of biological organisation

• Published in: International journal of science education Vol. 46; no. 14; pp. 1405 - 1431
• Main Authors: Thyberg, Annika, Schönborn, Konrad, Gericke, Niklas
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London Routledge 21.09.2024; Taylor & Francis Ltd
• Subjects: Biologi; Biology; Communication; Educational Practices; Educational Work; Epigenetics; Focus Groups; Levels of biological organization; Meaning; Pedagogiskt arbete; Science education; Student Characteristics; Students; Subject-specific education; Teaching; Utterances; Visual representations; Yo-yo reasoning; Ämnesdidaktik; Levels of biological organization; yo-yo reasoning; visual representations
• ISSN: 0950-0693; 1464-5289; 1464-5289
• DOI: 10.1080/09500693.2023.2289175

The aim of this study is to investigate students' meaning-making of multiple visual representations of epigenetics at different levels of biological organisation, and to discern what visual aspects of the multiple visual representations might influence students' reasoning. Adopting an exploratory approach, we analysed how students made meaning of visually communicated epigenetics phenomena while pointing at and reasoning about the multiple visual representations as part of semi-structured focus groups. We investigated students' meaning-making of the multiple visual representations by analysing their indications through physical pointing and accompanying verbal utterances. The analysis revealed meaning-making and the nature of linking between levels of organisation in four distinct patterns, namely intra horizontal linking, inter horizontal linking, one level vertical linking and two level vertical linking. In addition, five different visual characteristics of the multiple visual representations emerged as influencing students' reasoning while linking between different organisation levels: multiple visual representations, salient visual features, analogous visual features, familiar visual elements, and textual adjuncts. The study shows that multiple visual representations at different levels of organisation can support students' meaning-making of epigenetics, indicating that this way of communicating can be transferable to other biological domains. Potential implications for future research and teaching practice are provided.