Evolution of both host resistance and tolerance to an emerging bacterial pathogen

• Published in: Evolution letters Vol. 3; no. 5; pp. 544 - 554
• Main Authors: Bonneaud, Camille, Tardy, Luc, Giraudeau, Mathieu, Hill, Geoffrey E., McGraw, Kevin J., Wilson, Alastair J.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London John Wiley & Sons, Inc 01.10.2019; Wiley Open Access; Oxford University Press
• Subjects: Animal biology; Coevolution; Disease; Disease resistance; Epidemiology; Evolution; house finch; Immune clearance; Immune response; Immunological tolerance; Immunology; Infections; infectious disease; Life Sciences; Mycoplasma gallisepticum; Pathogens; Population studies; tolerance; Veterinary medicine and animal Health; Virulence; United States > US; Arizona; virulence; Coevolution; infectious disease; house finch; tolerance; Mycoplasma gallisepticum
• ISSN: 2056-3744; 2056-3744
• DOI: 10.1002/evl3.133

Understanding how hosts minimize the cost of emerging infections has fundamental implications for epidemiological dynamics and the evolution of pathogen virulence. Despite this, few experimental studies in natural populations have tested whether, in response to disease emergence, hosts evolve resistance, which reduces pathogen load through immune activation, or tolerance, which limits somatic damages without decreasing pathogen load. Further, none has done so accounting for significant natural variation in pathogen virulence, despite known effects on host responses to infection. Here, we investigate whether eastern North American house finches (Haemorhous mexicanus) have evolved resistance and/or tolerance to their emerging bacterial pathogen, Mycoplasma gallisepticum. To do so, we inoculated finches from disease‐exposed and disease‐unexposed populations with 55 distinct isolates of varying virulence. First, although peak pathogen loads, which occurred approximately eight days postinoculation, did not differ between experimentally inoculated finches from disease‐exposed versus unexposed population, pathogen loads subsequently decreased faster and to a greater extent in finches from exposed populations. These results suggest that finches from exposed populations are able to clear the infection through adaptive immune processes. Second, however, finches from exposed populations also displayed lower symptom severity for a given pathogen load, suggesting that a damage‐limitation mechanism, or tolerance, has accompanied the evolution of immune clearance. Our results highlight that resistance and tolerance should be seen as complementary, not alternative, defense strategies: the evolution of resistance benefits from the concomitant evolution of tolerance mechanisms that protect against the damage of immune activation, whereas the evolution of tolerance without resistance will risk runaway selection on pathogen virulence.