A turn in species conservation for hairpin banksias: demonstration of oversplitting leads to better management of diversity

• Published in: American journal of botany Vol. 109; no. 10; pp. 1652 - 1671
• Main Authors: Wilson, Trevor C., Rossetto, Maurizio, Bain, David, Yap, Jia‐Yee S., Wilson, Peter D., Stimpson, Margaret L., Weston, Peter H., Croft, Larry
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Botanical Society of America, Inc 01.10.2022; John Wiley and Sons Inc
• Subjects: Australia; Banksia; Biodiversity; Biological Evolution; Conservation; Conserved sequence; cpDNA; DArTseq; Endangered species; Flowering; Genetic structure; genome‐wide analysis; Genomic analysis; Historical structures; last glacial maximum; Morphology; Next-generation sequencing; Phylogeny; Population (statistical); Population statistics; Proteaceae; Proteaceae - genetics; Shrubs; single nucleotide polymorphism; species boundaries; Species classification; Species diversity; Taxonomy; threatened species; Wildlife conservation; Australia; DArTseq; last glacial maximum; species boundaries; genome-wide analysis; single nucleotide polymorphism; threatened species; Proteaceae; taxonomy; cpDNA; Banksia
• ISSN: 0002-9122; 1537-2197; 1537-2197
• DOI: 10.1002/ajb2.16074

Premise Understanding evolutionary history and classifying discrete units of organisms remain overwhelming tasks, and lags in this workload concomitantly impede an accurate documentation of biodiversity and conservation management. Rapid advances and improved accessibility of sensitive high‐throughput sequencing tools are fortunately quickening the resolution of morphological complexes and   thereby improving the estimation of species diversity. The recently described and critically endangered Banksia vincentia is morphologically similar to the hairpin banksia complex (B. spinulosa s.l.), a group of eastern Australian flowering shrubs whose continuum of morphological diversity has been responsible for taxonomic controversy and possibly questionable conservation initiatives. Methods To assist conservation while testing the current taxonomy of this group, we used high‐throughput sequencing to infer a population‐scale evolutionary scenario for a sample set that is comprehensive in its representation of morphological diversity and a 2500‐km distribution. Results Banksia spinulosa s.l. represents two clades, each with an internal genetic structure shaped through historical separation by biogeographic barriers. This structure conflicts with the existing taxonomy for the group. Corroboration between phylogeny and population statistics aligns with the hypothesis that B. collina, B. neoanglica, and B. vincentia should not be classified as species. Conclusions The pattern here supports how morphological diversity can be indicative of a locally expressed suite of traits rather than relationship. Oversplitting in the hairpin banksias is atypical since genomic analyses often reveal that species diversity is underestimated. However, we show that erring on overestimation can yield negative consequences, such as the disproportionate prioritization of a geographically anomalous population.