Deficit discourse - the 'regime of truth' preceding the Cape York Welfare Reform

• Published in: Griffith law review Vol. 28; no. 3; pp. 303 - 325
• Main Author: Campbell, Fiona
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Routledge 03.07.2019
• Subjects: Aboriginal; Cape York; Debit cards; Deficit discourse; income management; Public welfare; Social problems; special measure; Torres Strait Islander; Torres Strait Islanders; welfare reform; AUSTRALIA; Queensland
• ISSN: 1038-3441; 1839-4205
• DOI: 10.1080/10383441.2019.1690739

The Cape York Welfare Reform (CYWR) income management regime commenced in 2008. While this regime was supported and funded by the Queensland and federal governments, it was essentially developed by the Cape York Institute for Policy and Leadership (CYI), which was known as an Aboriginal policy development think tank. Income management in Cape York involves quarantining between 60% and 90% of a person's social security payment, if the person is deemed to have breached particular social responsibilities. The decision to income manage social security payments of CYWR community members, was based on a belief and writings by the CYI that there was a social norms deficit in Cape York communities, which income management could play a role in addressing. The language used by the CYI to describe Cape York community life was negative in the extreme, dramatic and evocative. This language, which I describe as deficit discourse, commanded a response to what was described as a dire situation. This article frames this deficit discourse in the broader and continuing context of colonisation. This discourse has been applied consistently throughout Australia's colonial history, perpetuating racial discrimination and justifying continuous governmental intervention into Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people's lives.