The Effect of Legal Environment on Voluntary Disclosure: Evidence from Management Earnings Forecasts Issued in U.S. and Canadian Markets

• Published in: The Accounting review Vol. 77; no. 1; pp. 25 - 50
• Main Authors: Baginski, Stephen P., Hassell, John M., Kimbrough, Michael D.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Sarasota American Accounting Association 01.01.2002
• Subjects: Accounting; Analysis; Analytical forecasting; Asymmetric information; Canada; Coefficients; Comparative analysis; Comparative studies; Corporations; Disclosure; Earnings; Earnings forecasting; Forecasting models; Forecasts; Industrial regulation; Information; Interpretation and construction; Investments; Laws, regulations and rules; Legal liability; Liability; Litigation; Management; Point estimators; Point forecasts; Securities law; Statistical forecasts; Stockholders' derivative actions; U.S.A; Canada; United States; United States > US
• ISSN: 0001-4826; 1558-7967
• DOI: 10.2308/accr.2002.77.1.25

Citing fear of legal liability as a partial explanation, prior research documents (1) managers' reluctance to voluntarily disclose management earnings forecasts, and (2) greater forecast disclosure frequencies in periods of bad news. We provide evidence on how management earnings forecast disclosure differs between the United States (U.S.) and Canada, two otherwise similar business environments with different legal regimes. Canadian securities laws and judicial interpretations create a far less litigious environment than exists in the U.S. We find a greater frequency of management earnings forecast disclosure in Canada relative to the U.S. Further, although U.S. managers are relatively more likely to issue forecasts during interim periods in which earnings decrease, Canadian managers do not exhibit that tendency. Instead, Canadian managers issue more forecasts when earnings are increasing, and their forecasts are of annual rather than interim earnings. Also consistent with a less litigious environment, Canadian managers issue more precise and longer-term forecasts. These findings hold after controlling for other determinants of management earnings forecast disclosure that might differ between the two countries-firm size, earnings volatility, information asymmetry, growth, capitalization rates, and membership in high-technology and regulated industries.