Adjusted to reality? Mandate and functioning of the General Integral Commission of the Grande Tárcoles Rivershed in Costa Rica

• Published in: Ecology and society Vol. 28; no. 4; p. 22
• Main Authors: Schröter, Barbara, Castro-Arce, Karina, Aguilar-González, Bernardo
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Ottawa Resilience Alliance 01.12.2023
• Subjects: Accountability; Annan samhällsvetenskap; Basins; Case studies; Citizen participation; Decision making; Environmental management; Financial institutions; institutional analysis; institutional interplay; Institutions; integrated water resources management; Latin America; Other Social Sciences; Qualitative analysis; Resource management; river basin organizations; River basins; Rivers; Samhällsvetenskap; Social Sciences; Social Sciences Interdisciplinary; Tribunals & commissions; Tvärvetenskapliga studier inom samhällsvetenskap; water governance; Water pollution; Water resources; Water resources management; Water rights; Water supply; Watershed management; Latin America; Costa Rica
• ISSN: 1708-3087; 1708-3087
• DOI: 10.5751/ES-14597-280422

The Grande de Tárcoles River in Costa Rica is one of the most polluted and degraded river basins in Central America. At the same time Costa Rica is a country internationally recognized for progressive environmental management. At least on paper, the country fosters sustainable river management in the form of integrated water resources management (IWRM). In the specific case of the Grande de Tárcoles River there is the General Integral Commission of the Grande Tárcoles River basin (CGICRGT) assigned to manage the basin in an integral manner. How this works in practice has so far not been investigated. Therefore, in this article we examine the formal and informal design and working practices of the CGICRGT and determine which type of river basin organization (RBO) it represents. Based on a mixed-method approach combining document analysis with semi-structured qualitative interviews we found that the CGICRGT contains elements of both, an agency RBO and a coordinating RBO. Although coordinating the river management works well to a certain extent, critical challenges remain that hinder a fully successful management of the basin and in consequence the improvement of its ecological status. Amongst them count the overlapping responsibilities of national and local institutions, the missing participation of some important institutions, the lack of financial and personnel resources, slow progress in terms of time, and a lack of motivation of the participating institutions. Although the CGICRGT presents an excellent platform for the integrated management of the Tárcoles river basin its progress will be too slow and its impact too small as long as all participants do not prioritize its work and integrate and motivate all important actors.