Exposure to the Death of Others during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Growing Mistrust in Medical Institutions as a Result of Personal Loss

• Published in: Behavioral sciences Vol. 13; no. 12; p. 999
• Main Authors: Gully, Brian J, Padovano, Hayley Treloar, Clark, Samantha E, Muro, Gabriel J, Monnig, Mollie A
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Switzerland MDPI AG 01.12.2023
• Subjects: Anxiety; Behavior; COVID-19; COVID-19 vaccines; death exposure; Disease control; Disease transmission; Drug overdose; Epidemics; Hypotheses; Mortality; mortality salience; pandemic; Pandemics; personal loss; Public policy; Safety and security measures; Self esteem; terror management theory; Threats; United States > US; COVID-19; medical mistrust; mortality salience; personal loss; terror management theory; pandemic; public health; death exposure
• ISSN: 2076-328X; 2076-328X
• DOI: 10.3390/bs13120999

The prominence of death during the COVID-19 pandemic was heightened by the potential of personally knowing someone who lost their life to the virus. The terror management theory (TMT) suggests that the salient presence of death has a pronounced effect on behavior and may result in the ossification of beliefs and actions aligned with one's worldview (i.e., the mortality salience hypothesis). In this study, we evaluated how death exposure early in the COVID-19 pandemic could enact the process of firming up held beliefs and attitudes related to health and safety. Specifically, we tested the hypothesis that exposure to a personal loss during the pandemic would strengthen participants' baseline attitudes and behaviors regarding COVID-19 safety guidelines. Data were analyzed from a prospective, regional survey administered at two time points during the pandemic, June-July 2020 and May 2021, in five United States northeastern states. Baseline and follow-up surveys were administered approximately 12 months apart, with adherence to public guidance and death exposure measured at both timepoints and other safety measures at follow-up only. Our results indicated that there were significant main effects of death exposure on guideline adherence and support for COVID-related public policy. Contrary to the mortality salience hypothesis, death exposures after baseline were related to higher medical mistrust at follow-up for those high in adherence at baseline, rather than those with low adherence. Our results offer some conflicting evidence to the mortality salience hypothesis. Rather than entrench people in their worldviews, death in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic appeared to sway people away from their initial stances. This finding has important implications for TMT literature and for the COVID-19 pandemic response.