Temperature as a key driver of ecological sorting among invasive pest species in the tropical Andes

• Published in: Ecological applications Vol. 18; no. 7; pp. 1795 - 1809
• Main Authors: Dangles, O, Carpio, C, Barragan, A.R, Zeddam, J.L, Silvain, J.F
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States 01.10.2008
• Subjects: accuracy; air temperature; altitude; Animals; climate change; Conservation of Natural Resources; Demography; ecosystem services; Ecuador; fecundity; Gelechiidae; geographical distribution; insect pests; invasive species; Larva - physiology; Moths - physiology; mountains; Ovum - physiology; Phthorimaea operculella; phytogeography; plant pests; population dynamics; prediction; Pupa - physiology; regression analysis; simulation models; spatial distribution; species differences; Symmetrischema tangolias; Tecia solanivora; Temperature; Tropical Climate; Ecuador; Andes region
• ISSN: 1051-0761; 1939-5582
• DOI: 10.1890/07-1638.1

Invasive species are a major threat to the sustainable provision of ecosystem products and services, both in natural and agricultural ecosystems. To understand the spatial arrangement of species successively introduced into the same ecosystem, we examined the tolerance to temperature and analyzed the field distribution of three potato tuber moths (PTM, Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae), that were introduced in Ecuador since the 1980s. We studied physiological responses to constant temperatures of the three PTM species under laboratory conditions and modeled consequences for their overall population dynamics. We then compared our predictions to field abundances of PTM adults collected in 42 sites throughout central Ecuador. Results showed that the three PTM species differed with respect to their physiological response to temperature. Symmetrischema tangolias was more cold tolerant while Tecia solanivora had the highest growth rates at warmer temperatures. Phthorimaea operculella showed the poorest physiological performance across the range of tested temperatures. Overall, field distributions agree with predictions based on physiological experiments and life table analyses. At elevations >3000 m, the most cold-tolerant species, S. tangolias, was typically dominant and often the only species present. This species may therefore represent a biological sensor of climate change. At low elevations (<2700 m), T. solanivora was generally the most abundant species, probably due to its high fecundity at high temperatures. At mid elevations, the three species co-occurred, but P. operculella was generally the least abundant species. Consistent with these qualitative results, significant regression analyses found that the best predictors of field abundance were temperature and a species x temperature interaction term. Our results suggest that the climatic diversity in agricultural landscapes can directly affect the community composition following sequential invasions. In the tropical Andes, as in other mountain ecosystems, the wide range of thermal environments found along elevational gradients may be one reason why the risks of invasion by successively introduced pest species could increase in the near future. More data on potential biological risks associated with climatic warming trends in mountain systems are therefore urgently needed, especially in developing nations where such studies are lacking.