Willingness to exit the artisanal fishery as a response to scenarios of declining catch or increasing monetary incentives

• Published in: Fisheries research Vol. 111; no. 1; pp. 74 - 81
• Main Authors: Muallil, Richard N., Geronimo, Rollan C., Cleland, Deborah, Cabral, Reniel B., Doctor, Maria Victoria, Cruz-Trinidad, Annabelle, Aliño, Porfirio M.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Amsterdam Elsevier B.V 01.09.2011; Elsevier
• Subjects: Alternative livelihood; Animal, plant and microbial ecology; Applied ecology; Biological and medical sciences; Exploitation and management of natural biological resources (hunting, fishing and exploited populations survey, etc.); Fishing pressure; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; Poverty; Small-scale fishers; Socioeconomic factors; ISEW, South China Sea; ISEW, Philippines; Alternative livelihood; Poverty; Fishing pressure; Small-scale fishers; Socioeconomic factors; Fishery; Small scale; Socioeconomics; Capture; Artisanal fishing
• ISSN: 0165-7836; 1872-6763
• DOI: 10.1016/j.fishres.2011.06.013

► There is a high heterogeneity in fishers’ willingness to exit from the fishery both in response to declining catch or increasing monetary incentives. ► At least 51% of the fishers were willing to exit the fishery when monetary incentives are about the same as their average household expenses. This proportion increased to 82% when the amount was about 1.5 times their household expenses. ► Considerable proportion of fishers persist in the fishery at catch levels below economic profitability or even when offered with high monetary incentives. ► Fishers who were newer to the fishery, exerting less fishing effort showed more willingness to exit the fishery for both catch and monetary incentive scenarios. ► Middle aged fishers (36–50 years old) were more likely to exit the fishery than younger fishers and older ones in response to declining catch. The coastal ecosystems of the Philippines are among the most heavily fished areas in the world. High dependency on fishery resources by an expanding population have resulted in overexploited and deteriorated fish stocks, perpetuating widespread poverty in fishing communities. Reducing fishing pressure through livelihood support provision for fishers could potentially alleviate poverty and mitigate deteriorating fisheries at the same time. However, this requires understanding fishers’ behavior toward exiting the fishery and how different socioeconomic factors affect this behavior. We determined fishers’ willingness to exit the fishery for different catch and monetary incentive scenarios in 6 coastal towns in the South China Sea biogeographic region of the Philippines. Half the fishers surveyed would continue fishing even when catches fall to 0.5 kg a day. This translates to less than US$1 gross income which is only about 15% of the daily fishers’ household expenses in the studied towns. For monetary incentives, 18% of fishers were already willing to exit the fishery at US$111 monthly incentives. This proportion increased to 51% when the offer was increased to US$222 which is about the same as the fishers’ monthly household expenses. When the offer was increased to US$333, 18% of fishers still said they would prefer to continue fishing. Fishers who were newer to the fishery and exerting less fishing effort showed more willingness to exit the fishery for both catch and monetary incentive scenarios. Age and educational attainment also influenced fishers’ exit decision. These findings demonstrate high heterogeneity in fishers’ behavior toward exiting the fishery and that properly targeting those who are more willing to exit the fishery in livelihood programs might both effectively reduce fishing pressure and give fish stocks and other marine ecosystems a chance to recover while improving the fishers’ well-being.