A social network approach to analyzing water governance: The case of the Mkindo catchment, Tanzania

• Published in: Physics and chemistry of the earth. Part B, Hydrology, oceans and atmosphere Vol. 36; no. 14-15; pp. 1085 - 1092
• Main Authors: Stein, C., Ernstson, H., Barron, J.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier Ltd 2011
• Subjects: Catchment management; Catchments; Construction; Freshwater; Hydrology; Networks; Resource management; Social network analysis; Social networks; Tanzania; Villages; Water governance; Water resources; Tanzania; Social network analysis; Catchment management; Water governance; Water resources; Tanzania
• ISSN: 1474-7065; 1873-5193; 1464-1909; 1873-4677; 1873-5193
• DOI: 10.1016/j.pce.2011.07.083

► Water governance is more complex than suggested by formal policy. ► Local informal actors perform important functions. ► Interventions need to work through complex webs of social relations. ► Social network analysis proven valuable for analyzing social structures. ► Building on existing social structures could improve water governance. The governance dimension of water resources management is just as complex and interconnected as the hydrological processes it aims to influence. There is an increasing need (i) to understand the multi-stakeholder governance arrangements that emerge from the cross-scale nature and multifunctional role of water; and (ii) to develop appropriate research tools to analyze them. In this study we demonstrate how social network analysis (SNA), a well-established technique from sociology and organizational research, can be used to empirically map collaborative social networks between actors that either directly or indirectly influence water flows in the Mkindo catchment in Tanzania. We assess how these collaborative social networks affect the capacity to govern water in this particular catchment and explore how knowledge about such networks can be used to facilitate more effective or adaptive water resources management. The study is novel as it applies social network analysis not only to organizations influencing blue water (the liquid water in rivers, lakes and aquifers) but also green water (the soil moisture used by plants). Using a questionnaire and semi-structured interviews, we generated social network data of 70 organizations, ranging from local resource users and village leaders, to higher-level governmental agencies, universities and NGOs. Results show that there is no organization that coordinates the various land and water related activities at the catchment scale. Furthermore, an important result is that village leader play a crucial role linking otherwise disconnected actors, but that they are not adequately integrated into the formal water governance system. Water user associations (WUAs) are in the process of establishment and could bring together actors currently not part of the formal governance system. However, the establishment of WUAs seems to follow a top-down approach not considering the existing informal organization of water users that are revealed through this social network analysis. Instead of imposing institutional arrangements, we argue that it is more promising to identify and build on existing social structures. Social network analysis can help to identify existing social structures and points for interventions to increase the problem solving capacity of the governance network.