Results of the “carbon conference” international aerosol carbon round robin test stage I

• Published in: Atmospheric environment (1994) Vol. 35; no. 12; pp. 2111 - 2121
• Main Authors: Schmid, Heidrun, Laskus, Lothar, Jürgen Abraham, Hans, Baltensperger, Urs, Lavanchy, Vincent, Bizjak, Mirko, Burba, Peter, Cachier, Helene, Crow, Dale, Chow, Judith, Gnauk, Thomas, Even, Arja, ten Brink, H.M, Giesen, Klaus-Peter, Hitzenberger, Regina, Hueglin, Christoph, Maenhaut, Willy, Pio, Casimiro, Carvalho, Abel, Putaud, Jean-Philippe, Toom-Sauntry, Desiree, Puxbaum, Hans
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford Elsevier Ltd 01.01.2001; Elsevier Science
• Subjects: Analysis methods; Applied sciences; Atmospheric pollution; Earth, ocean, space; Elemental carbon; Exact sciences and technology; External geophysics; Intercomparison; Meteorology; Particles and aerosols; Pollution; Pyrolysis; Soot; Thermal–optical method; Europe; Germany; Intercomparison; Thermal–optical method; Elemental carbon; Pyrolysis; Soot; Organic carbon; Thermal method; Air quality; Urban area; Round robin test; Carbon; Ambient air measurement; Suspended particle; Ambient air concentration; Quartz fiber; Aerosols; Optical method; Air pollution; Measurement method; Sampling; Fiber filter
• ISSN: 1352-2310; 1873-2844
• DOI: 10.1016/S1352-2310(00)00493-3

An international round robin test on the analysis of carbonaceous aerosols on quartz fiber filters sampled at an urban site was organized by the Vienna University of Technology. Seventeen laboratories participated using nine different thermal and optical methods. For the analysis of total carbon (TC), a good agreement of the values obtained by all laboratories was found (7 and 9% r.s.d.) with only two outliers in the complete data set. In contrast the results of the determination of elemental carbon (EC) in two not pre-extracted samples were highly variable ranging over more than one order of magnitude and the relative standard deviations (r.s.d.) of the means were 36.6 and 45.5%. The laboratories that obtained similar results by using methods which reduce the charring artifact were put together to a new data set in order to approach a “real EC” value. The new data set consisting of the results of 10 laboratories using seven different methods showed 16 and 24% lower averages and r.s.d. of 14 and 24% for the two not pre-extracted samples. Taking the current filters as “equivalents” for urban aerosol samples we conclude that the following methods can be used for the analysis of EC in carbonaceous aerosols: thermal methods with an optical feature to correct for charring during pyrolysis, two-step thermal procedures reducing charring during pyrolysis, the VDI 2465/1 method (removal of OC by solvent extraction and thermodesorption in nitrogen) and the VDI 2465/2 method (combustion of OC and EC at different temperatures) with an additional pre-extraction with a dimethyl formamide (DMF)/toluene mixture. Only thermal methods without any correction for charring during pyrolysis and the VDI 2465/2 method were outside the range of twice the standard deviation of the new data set. For a filter sample pre-extracted with the DMF/toluene mixture the average and r.s.d. from all laboratories (20.7 μgC; 24.4% r.s.d.) was very similar as for the laboratory set reduced to 10 laboratories (20.6 μgC; 19% r.s.d.). Thus DMF pre-extraction appears to improve the performance of the thermal methods without charring during pyrolysis control, e.g. the VDI 2465/2 methods.