The Effect of Mental Health App Customization on Depressive Symptoms in College Students: Randomized Controlled Trial

• Published in: JMIR mental health Vol. 9; no. 8; p. e39516
• Main Authors: Six, Stephanie G, Byrne, Kaileigh A, Aly, Heba, Harris, Maggie W
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Toronto JMIR Publications 09.08.2022
• Subjects: Age groups; Anxiety; Clinical trials; Cognitive therapy; College students; Comorbidity; Customization; Diaries; Emotions; Gamification; Hypotheses; Mental depression; Mental disorders; Mental health; Original Paper; Portable computers; Stress; Usability
• ISSN: 2368-7959; 2368-7959
• DOI: 10.2196/39516

Background Mental health apps have shown promise in improving mental health symptoms, including depressive symptoms. However, limited research has been aimed at understanding how specific app features and designs can optimize the therapeutic benefits and adherence to such mental health apps. Objective The primary purpose of this study is to investigate the effect of avatar customization on depressive symptoms and adherence to use a novel cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)–based mental health app. The secondary aim is to examine whether specific app features, including journaling, mood tracking, and reminders, affect the usability of the mental health app. Methods College students were recruited from a university study recruitment pool website and via flyer advertisements throughout campus. A total of 94 participants completed a randomized controlled trial in which they were randomized to either customization or no customization version of the app. Customization involved personalizing a virtual avatar and a travel vehicle to one’s own preferences and use of one’s name throughout the app. Participants completed a 14-day trial using a novel CBT-based mental health app called AirHeart. Self-report scores for depressive symptoms, anxiety, and stress were measured at baseline and after the intervention. Postintervention survey measures also included usability and avatar identification questionnaires. Results Of the 94 enrolled participants, 83 (88%) completed the intervention and postintervention assessments. AirHeart app use significantly reduced symptoms of depression (P=.006) from baseline to the end of the 2-week intervention period for all participants, regardless of the customization condition. However, no differences in depressive symptoms (P=.17) or adherence (P=.80) were observed between the customization (39/83, 47%) and no customization (44/83, 53%) conditions. The frequency of journaling, usefulness of mood tracking, and helpfulness of reminders were not associated with changes in depressive symptoms or adherence (P>.05). Exploratory analyses showed that there were 3 moderate positive correlations between avatar identification and depressive symptoms (identification: r=−0.312, P=.02; connection: r=−0.305, P=.02; and lack of relatability: r=0.338, P=.01). Conclusions These results indicate that CBT mental health apps, such as AirHeart, have the potential to reduce depressive symptoms over a short intervention period. The randomized controlled trial results demonstrated that customization of app features, such as avatars, does not further reduce depressive symptoms over and above the CBT modules and standard app features, including journal, reminders, and mood tracking. However, further research elucidating the relationship between virtual avatar identification and mental health systems is needed as society becomes increasingly more digitized. These findings have potential implications for improving the optimization of mental health app designs. Trial Registration Open Science Framework t28gm; https://osf.io/t28gm