An evaluation of Poisson-Boltzmann electrostatic free energy calculations through comparison with experimental mutagenesis data

• Published in: Biopolymers Vol. 95; no. 11; pp. 746 - 754
• Main Authors: Gorham Jr, Ronald D., Kieslich, Chris A., Nichols, Aaron, Sausman, Noriko U., Foronda, Marisse, Morikis, Dimitrios
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Hoboken Wiley Subscription Services, Inc., A Wiley Company 01.11.2011
• Subjects: alanine scan; Charging; Coefficients; continuum electrostatics; Correlation; Coulombic free energy; Dielectrics; electrostatically-driven association; Electrostatics; excessive charge; Free energy; Mathematical analysis; Models, Molecular; Mutagenesis; protein dielectric; protein salvation; Proteins; solvation free energy; Static Electricity
• ISSN: 0006-3525; 1097-0282; 1097-0282
• DOI: 10.1002/bip.21644

For systems involving highly and oppositely charged proteins, electrostatic forces dominate association and contribute to biomolecular complex stability. Using experimental or theoretical alanine‐scanning mutagenesis, it is possible to elucidate the contribution of individual ionizable amino acids to protein association. We evaluated our electrostatic free energy calculations by comparing calculated and experimental data for alanine mutants of five protein complexes. We calculated Poisson–Boltzmann electrostatic free energies based on a thermodynamic cycle, which incorporates association in a reference (Coulombic) and solvated (solution) state, as well as solvation effects. We observe that Coulombic and solvation free energy values correlate with experimental data in highly and oppositely charged systems, but not in systems comprised of similarly charged proteins. We also observe that correlation between solution and experimental free energies is dependent on dielectric coefficient selection for the protein interior. Free energy correlations improve as protein dielectric coefficient increases, suggesting that the protein interior experiences moderate dielectric screening, despite being shielded from solvent. We propose that higher dielectric coefficients may be necessary to more accurately predict protein–protein association. Additionally, our data suggest that Coulombic potential calculations alone may be sufficient to predict relative binding of protein mutants. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 95: 746‐754, 2011.