Multi-tracer experiments to characterise contaminant mitigation capacities for different types of artificial wetlands

• Published in: International journal of environmental analytical chemistry Vol. 91; no. 7-8; pp. 768 - 785
• Main Authors: Lange, Jens, Schuetz, Tobias, Gregoire, Caroline, Elsässer, David, Schulz, Ralf, Passeport, Elodie, Tournebize, Julien
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Abingdon Taylor & Francis Group 01.01.2011; Taylor & Francis LLC; Taylor & Francis
• Subjects: Artificial wetlands; Chemical contaminants; constructed wetlands; contaminant mitigation; Environmental Sciences; Flowers & plants; fluid mechanics; fluorescent tracers; forests; isoproturon; overland flow; Pesticides; Phragmites australis; reference tracer; residence time distribution; sodium; sodium chloride; Sorption; surface flow wetlands; surface water; tracer techniques
• ISSN: 1029-0397; 0306-7319; 1029-0397
• DOI: 10.1080/03067319.2010.525635

Salt tracers (sodium bromide/sodium chloride) and two different fluorescent tracers, uranine (UR) and sulforhodamine-B (SRB), were injected as a pulse into six different surface flow wetlands (SFWs). Salt tracers documented wetland hydraulics. The fluorescent tracers were used as a reference to mimic photolytic decay (UR) and sorption (SRB) of contaminants as illustrated by a comparison to a real herbicide (Isoproturon), which was used as a model for mobile pesticides. Tracer breakthrough curves were used to document residence time distributions, hydraulic efficiencies, peak attenuation and retention capacities of completely different wetland systems. A 530 m² forest buffer zone showed considerable peak attenuation but limited retention capabilities despite its large area. Approximately 80% of SRB was permanently retained in a re-structured 325 m² flood detention pond. These two non-steady SFWs indicated long-term tracer washout. The remaining four SFWs displayed constant outflow rates and steady-state flow conditions. Due to photolytic decay in a 330 m² row of three wetlands, UR was almost entirely degraded, but the SRB breakthrough suggested relatively low sorption. A 65 m² shallow flow-through wetland yielded negligible photolytic decay but showed considerable sorption losses. Finally two types of vegetated ditches were analysed. In one case, vegetation was removed from a 413 m long ditch immediately prior to tracer injection. A 30% loss by sorption to sediment and plant remnants occurred at the very beginning of the tracer breakthrough. Inside a second ditch, 80 m long and densely vegetated by Phragmites australis, sorption was even higher and yielded eightfold higher specific SRB retention rates. Although the present findings are only valid for low flow conditions, they indicate that a shallow water depth seems to be a key variable which may increase sorption of tracers and therefore contaminants. Large wetlands with deep water bodies may attenuate concentrations efficiently, but unit load reduction was found to be more significant in shallow systems even at much higher flow velocities.