Three Spatial Verification Techniques: Cluster Analysis, Variogram, and Optical Flow

• Published in: Weather and forecasting Vol. 24; no. 6; pp. 1457 - 1471
• Main Authors: MARZBAN, Caren, SANDGATHE, Scott, LYONS, Hilary, LEDERER, Nicholas
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Boston, MA American Meteorological Society 01.12.2009
• Subjects: Cluster analysis; Clustering; Datasets; Decomposition; Earth, ocean, space; Euclidean space; Exact sciences and technology; External geophysics; False alarms; Fields; Flow mapping; Meteorology; Methods; Optical flow (image analysis); Precipitation; Spatial analysis; Statistical methods; Verification; Weather forecasting; Cluster analysis; intensity; covariance; Analysis method
• ISSN: 0882-8156; 1520-0434
• DOI: 10.1175/2009WAF2222261.1

Abstract Three spatial verification techniques are applied to three datasets. The datasets consist of a mixture of real and artificial forecasts, and corresponding observations, designed to aid in better understanding the effects of global (i.e., across the entire field) displacement and intensity errors. The three verification techniques, each based on well-known statistical methods, have little in common and, so, present different facets of forecast quality. It is shown that a verification method based on cluster analysis can identify “objects” in a forecast and an observation field, thereby allowing for object-oriented verification in the sense that it considers displacement, missed forecasts, and false alarms. A second method compares the observed and forecast fields, not in terms of the objects within them, but in terms of the covariance structure of the fields, as summarized by their variogram. The last method addresses the agreement between the two fields by inferring the function that maps one to the other. The map—generally called optical flow—provides a (visual) summary of the “difference” between the two fields. A further summary measure of that map is found to yield useful information on the distortion error in the forecasts.