Characterizing fracture energy of proton exchange membranes using a knife slit test

• Published in: Journal of polymer science. Part B, Polymer physics Vol. 48; no. 3; pp. 333 - 343
• Main Authors: Patankar, Kshitish, Dillard, David A, Case, Scott W, Ellis, Michael W, Li, Yongqiang, Lai, Yeh-Hung, Budinski, Michael K, Gittleman, Craig S
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Hoboken Wiley Subscription Services, Inc., A Wiley Company 01.02.2010; Wiley
• Subjects: Applied sciences; Cutlery; Cutting; Durability; durability of proton exchange membranes; Energy use; Exact sciences and technology; Exchange resins and membranes; failure; Forms of application and semi-finished materials; fracture; fracture energy; Fracture mechanics; Fracture toughness; Humidity; intrinsic fracture; knife slit test; Membranes; Polymer industry, paints, wood; proton exchange membranes (PEM); Technology of polymers; thin films; Ionomer; Fracture life; Mechanical properties; Temperature effect; proton exchange membranes (PEM); Experimental study; durability of proton exchange membranes; Sulfonate copolymer; fracture; thin films; Tetrafluoroethylene copolymer; Humidity effect; knife slit test; failure; Cation exchange membrane; Fracture mechanics test; Measurement method; Fracture energy; intrinsic fracture
• ISSN: 0887-6266; 1099-0488; 1099-0488
• DOI: 10.1002/polb.21894

Pinhole formation in proton exchange membranes (PEM) may be caused by a process of flaw formation and crack propagation within membranes exposed to cyclic hygrothermal loading. Fracture mechanics can be used to characterize the propagation process, which is thought to occur in a slow, time-dependent manner under cyclic loading conditions, and believed to be associated with limited plasticity. The intrinsic fracture energy has been used to characterize the fracture resistance of polymeric material with limited viscoelastic and plastic dissipation, and has been found to be associated with long-term durability of polymeric materials. Insight into this limiting value of fracture energy may be useful in characterizing the durability of proton exchange membranes, including the formation of pinhole defects. In an effort to collect fracture data with limited plasticity, a knife slit test was adapted to measure fracture energies of PEMs, resulting in fracture energies that were two orders of magnitude smaller than those obtained with other fracture test methods. The presence of a sharp knife blade reduces crack tip plasticity, providing fracture energies that may be more representative of the intrinsic fracture energies of the thin membranes. Three commercial PEMs were tested to evaluate their fracture energies (Gc) at temperatures ranging from 40 to 90 °C and humidity levels varying from dry to 90% relative humidity (RH). Experiments were also conducted with membrane specimens immersed in water at various temperatures. The time temperature moisture superposition principle was applied to generate fracture energy master curves plotted as a function of reduced cutting rate based on the humidity and temperature conditions of the tests. The shift with respect to temperature and humidity suggests that the slitting process is viscoelastic in nature. Also such shifts were found to be consistent with those obtained from constitutive tests such as stress relaxation. The fracture energy is more sensitive to temperature than on humidity. The master curves converge at the lowest reduced cutting rates, suggesting similar intrinsic fracture energies; but diverge at higher reduced cutting rates to significantly different fracture energies. Although the relationship between Gc and ultimate mechanical durability has not been established, the test method may hold promise for investigating and comparing membrane resistance to failure in fuel cell environments.