Narrating abandoned land: Perceptions of natural forest regrowth in Southwestern Europe

• Published in: Land use policy Vol. 99; p. 105034
• Main Authors: Frei, Theresa, Derks, Jakob, Rodríguez Fernández-Blanco, Carmen, Winkel, Georg
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Kidlington Elsevier Ltd 01.12.2020; Elsevier Science Ltd
• Subjects: Abandoned land; Agricultural land; Case studies; Cultural bias; Cultural values; Deforestation; Fatalism; Forest management; Forestry; Forests; Governance; Land abandonment; Land management; Land use; Landscape; Management; Narratives; Natural forest regrowth; Perceptions; Regrowth; Rewilding; Europe; Rewilding; Land abandonment; Perceptions; Cultural bias; Narratives; Natural forest regrowth
• ISSN: 0264-8377; 1873-5754
• DOI: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2020.105034

•Managing land use changes requires a better understanding of societal perceptions.•We assess actor group narratives on natural forest regrowth in Spain and France.•Different symbolic meanings exist, ranging from lost territory to recovered land.•There is common ground regarding natural forest regrowth management.•Cultural beliefs and site-specific contexts are key for management approaches. The abandonment of agricultural land leads to landscape changes in many parts of Europe, often followed by natural forest regrowth. These landscape changes have far-reaching social and ecological consequences. Our research addresses the question of how local actor groups involved in land management perceive natural forest regrowth on abandoned land. Based on 42 interviews with local actors, we analyse narratives on natural forest regrowth in four case studies, one in France and three in Spain. Across the case studies, we find three narratives: a rural fatalism narrative, a pro forest management narrative and a pro nature narrative, each with its own problem definitions and solution strategies on natural forest regrowth. Our analysis reveals regional nuances, which depend on land use characteristics that shape the perceptions of local actor groups. We conclude that natural forest regrowth holds different symbolic functions, ranging from lost territory to recovered land. Any assessment of trade-offs and opportunities needs to consider the local situation. Furthermore, management and governance approaches need to acknowledge different cultural beliefs, which shape the perception of actor groups.