Determination of “borderline resectable” pancreatic cancer – A global assessment of 30 shades of grey

• Published in: HPB (Oxford, England) Vol. 25; no. 11; pp. 1393 - 1401
• Main Authors: Badgery, Henry E., Muhlen-Schulte, Tjuntu, Zalcberg, John R., D'souza, Bianka, Gerstenmaier, Jan F., Pickett, Craig, Samra, Jaswinder, Croagh, Daniel, Ahmed, Farhan, Allan, Emel, Amelina, Inna, Aroori, Somaiah, Balendran, Nalayini, Ban, Ee J., Bartlett, David, Berry, Roger, Bezuidenhout, Abraham, Bhogal, Ricky, Bolan, Candice, Bolm, Louisa, Bonifacio, Cristiana, Borsaru, Adina, Burnett, David, Butterfield, Nick, Cannella, Roberto, Capretti, Giovanni, Carnelli, Carlos, Chatzizacharias, Nikolaos, Chingoli, Felix, Chu, Linda, Chu, Wai pong, Clark, Toshimasa, Connor, Saxon, Currin, Stephen, Daruwalla, Jurstine, De Santis, Domenico, Dhawan, Ankita, Di Muzio, Bruno, Dioguardi Burgio, Marco, Dunn, Joel, Gemenetzis, Georgios, Goodwin, Mark, Gray, Andrew, Halloran, Christopher, Harisis, George, Harris, Heather, He, Jin, Hecht, Elizabeth, Heumann, Asmus, Hodgson, Russell, Hui, Cathryn, Kalinin, Petr, Kleeff, Jorg, Ko, Hyun S., Kozyreva, Ksenia, Kutaiba, Numan, Lewin, Joel, Lim, Christopher, Lohöfer, Fabian, Loveday, Benjamin, Marchegiani, Giovanni, Mastrocostas, Katerina, Mavroeidis, Vasileios K., Merrett, Neil, Nebbia, Martina, Neoptolemos, John, Nesterov, Denis, Pilgrim, Charles, Reames, Bradley N., Rowcroft, Alistair, Seale, Melanie, Siddique, Sabbir, Smith, Marty, Sugrue, Gavin, Thakur, Jatin, Thomas, Rose, Tibermacine, Walid, Tolat, Parag, Triantopoulou, Charikleia, Trofimov, Stanislav, Uzunoglu, Faik G., Vernuccio, Federica, De Boo, Diederick W., Webber, Laurence, Wei, Alice, Wood, Verity, Zins, Marc
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Elsevier Ltd 01.11.2023
• Subjects: Adenocarcinoma - surgery; Carcinoma, Pancreatic Ductal - diagnostic imaging; Carcinoma, Pancreatic Ductal - drug therapy; Carcinoma, Pancreatic Ductal - surgery; Humans; Neoadjuvant Therapy; Pancreatic Neoplasms - diagnostic imaging; Pancreatic Neoplasms - pathology; Pancreatic Neoplasms - surgery; Tomography, X-Ray Computed - methods
• ISSN: 1365-182X; 1477-2574
• DOI: 10.1016/j.hpb.2023.07.883

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is an aggressive cancer with a poor prognosis. Accurate preoperative assessment using computed tomography (CT) to determine resectability is crucial in ensuring patients are offered the most appropriate therapeutic strategy. Despite the use of classification guidelines, any interobserver variability between reviewing surgeons and radiologists may confound decisions influencing patient treatment pathways. In this multicentre observational study, an international group of 96 clinicians (42 hepatopancreatobiliary surgeons and 54 radiologists) were surveyed and asked to report 30 pancreatic CT scans of pancreatic cancer deemed borderline at respective multidisciplinary meetings (MDM). The degree of interobserver agreement in resectability among radiologists and surgeons was assessed and subgroup regression analysis was performed. Interobserver variability between reviewers was high with no unanimous agreement. Overall interobserver agreement was fair with a kappa value of 0.32 with a higher rate of agreement among radiologists over surgeons. Interobserver variability among radiologists and surgeons globally is high, calling into question the consistency of clinical decision making for patients with PDAC and suggesting that central review may be required for studies of neoadjuvant or adjuvant approaches in future as well as ongoing quality control initiatives, even amongst experts in the field.